Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholatโ€ฆ

Humaniora editorial

Open AccessOA2023

A Documentary History of the Immunity (or Vaccine) Passport: Health Certificates of Public Health, Personal Identity and Power from the Plague to the Coronavirus Pandemic

This article presents a documentary history of the immunity passport, showing its diverse material forms and effects across four historical disease outbreaks, and argues that it has shaped identities, public health, and agency during health crises.
Marc R. H. Kosciejewยท Social history of medicineยท 2023ยท DOI 10.1093/shm/hkac077

The core problem

The immunity (or vaccine) passport, as a concept and object, is not unprecedented. This health and identity document features a history spanning over half-a-millennium and appearing across diverse geopolitical and sociocultural contexts. The article presents a documentary history of the immunity passport and its heterogeneous material instantiations, uses, and effects across divergent historical settings. It illuminates how the immunity passport has helped shape identities and public health, as well as impacted individual and institutional agency, during health crises. The study explores four historical cases: the plagues ravaging the Renaissance Mediterranean region, the 1665 Great Plague of London, the yellow fever outbreaks in the antebellum slave-era southern USA, and the chronic cholera conditions confronting colonial-era British India. Although disparate, these historical cases share the immunity passport as a non-pharmaceutical intervention into their respective health crises that played important roles in people's lives during these troubled times.

Innovation

The article employs a documentary history approach, analyzing primary and secondary sources to trace the material forms, uses, and effects of the immunity passport across four historical case studies. The methodology involves a comparative analysis of these cases, focusing on how the document functioned as a non-pharmaceutical intervention during health crises. The study examines the heterogeneous instantiations of the immunity passport, including its role in shaping identities, public health measures, and individual and institutional agency. By situating the immunity passport within its historical contexts, the article reveals continuities and discontinuities in its deployment from the Renaissance Mediterranean to the coronavirus pandemic.
Introduction
The immunity (or vaccine) passport, as a concept and object, is not unprecedented. This health and identity document features a history spanning over half-a-millennium and appearing across diverse geopolitical and sociocultural contexts. The article presents a documentary history of the immunity passport and its heterogeneous material instantiations, uses, and effects across divergent historical settings. It illuminates how the immunity passport has helped shape identities and public health, as well as impacted individual and institutional agency, during health crises. The study explores four historical cases: the plagues ravaging the Renaissance Mediterranean region, the 1665 Great Plague of London, the yellow fever outbreaks in the antebellum slave-era southern USA, and the chronic cholera conditions confronting colonial-era British India. Although disparate, these historical cases share the immunity passport as a non-pharmaceutical intervention into their respective health crises that played important roles in people's lives during these troubled times.

Why it matters

The historical cases demonstrate that the immunity passport is not merely a neutral public health tool but a document that shapes identities and power relations. It has been used to include or exclude individuals from society, to regulate mobility, and to reinforce social hierarchies. In the Renaissance Mediterranean, health certificates could stigmatize those from infected areas. In the antebellum South, they intersected with the institution of slavery, controlling the movement of enslaved people. In colonial India, they served as instruments of colonial governance. The article argues that the immunity passport's role as a non-pharmaceutical intervention has consistently involved negotiations of agency, with individuals and institutions employing the document to assert rights or enforce control. These historical insights illuminate contemporary debates about vaccine passports during the coronavirus pandemic, highlighting the need to consider their social and ethical implications.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member contentโ€ฆ