Ilmu Komputer & AI editorial
Open AccessOA2024
A Systematic Review of K-12 Cybersecurity Education Around the World
A systematic review of 24 academic papers and 19 gray literature sources reveals that K-12 cybersecurity education is fragmented, predominantly focused on secondary school, and lacks systematic teaching of key cybersecurity concepts worldwide.
A. Ibrahim; M. McKee; Leslie F. Sikos; Nicola F. Johnson· IEEE Access· 2024· DOI 10.1109/ACCESS.2024.3393425
The core problem
Cybersecurity has become a critical concern for individuals and societies globally, yet its integration into K-12 education remains inconsistent. This systematic review, published in IEEE Access, aims to synthesize the existing literature on K-12 cybersecurity education from around the world. The authors—A. Ibrahim, M. McKee, Leslie F. Sikos, and Nicola F. Johnson—identify a pressing need to understand how cybersecurity is taught, what competencies are targeted, and where gaps exist. Given the pervasive nature of digital technology, cybersecurity knowledge is relevant to every person using a digital device, making it essential to equip young learners with foundational skills. However, the interdisciplinary nature of the field introduces terminological ambiguity, complicating the synthesis of research. The review seeks to provide a comprehensive overview of the current state of K-12 cybersecurity education, highlighting common topics, required competencies, and areas for improvement.
Innovation
The authors conducted a systematic literature review following a predefined research protocol. They searched academic databases and gray literature sources, identifying 24 academic papers published between 2013 and 2023 that met the inclusion criteria. Additionally, 19 gray literature sources were included, resulting in a total of 43 sources. The review focused on extracting data related to cybersecurity topics, competencies, educational settings, and terminological usage. The analysis aimed to identify recurring themes and gaps in the literature. The methodology adhered to systematic review guidelines to ensure rigor and reproducibility, although specific details of the search strategy and inclusion criteria are not elaborated in the provided summary.
Introduction
Cybersecurity has become a critical concern for individuals and societies globally, yet its integration into K-12 education remains inconsistent. This systematic review, published in IEEE Access, aims to synthesize the existing literature on K-12 cybersecurity education from around the world. The authors—A. Ibrahim, M. McKee, Leslie F. Sikos, and Nicola F. Johnson—identify a pressing need to understand how cybersecurity is taught, what competencies are targeted, and where gaps exist. Given the pervasive nature of digital technology, cybersecurity knowledge is relevant to every person using a digital device, making it essential to equip young learners with foundational skills. However, the interdisciplinary nature of the field introduces terminological ambiguity, complicating the synthesis of research. The review seeks to provide a comprehensive overview of the current state of K-12 cybersecurity education, highlighting common topics, required competencies, and areas for improvement.
Why it matters
The findings reveal significant gaps in K-12 cybersecurity education. The predominant focus on secondary education leaves primary school students without foundational cybersecurity knowledge, potentially widening the digital divide and increasing vulnerability. The terminological ambiguity across studies hinders the development of a cohesive curriculum and the comparison of research outcomes. The authors argue that cybersecurity should be integrated systematically across all grade levels, with clear definitions and competencies. The interdisciplinary nature of cybersecurity means it intersects with computer science, digital literacy, and citizenship education, requiring a coordinated approach. The review underscores the need for standardized terminology and frameworks to guide curriculum development and teacher training. Furthermore, the lack of systematic teaching suggests that current efforts are ad hoc and insufficient to prepare students for the digital age. The authors call for more research focused on primary education and the development of age-appropriate cybersecurity curricula.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…