Pendidikan editorial
Open AccessOA2025
A Topological Exploration of Convergence/Divergence of Human-Mediated and Algorithmically Mediated Pedagogy
This paper proposes a topological model to examine the convergent and divergent dynamics between human-mediated and algorithmically mediated pedagogies, highlighting risks of pedagogical atrophy and the need to develop teachers' critical agency.
Keith Turvey; N. Pachlerยท British Journal of Educational Technologyยท 2025ยท DOI 10.1111/bjet.70007
The core problem
The rapid integration of Artificial Intelligence in Education (AIED) presents both opportunities and risks for pedagogical practice. The authors situate teachers' agency as a constituent element within the convergent and divergent dynamics at the intersection of human-mediated and algorithmically mediated pedagogies. They argue that while AI technologies can support pedagogical decision-making and meaning-making, there is a risk of pedagogical atrophy as human processes emulate and become increasingly dependent on AI. The paper aims to provide a critical lens for developing teachers' agency by examining these dynamics.
Innovation
The authors conduct an in-depth analysis of current literature to advance thinking about the dilemma presented by the need to meld algorithmically and human-mediated pedagogies. They propose an original topological model that maps the mediating influences of AIED and examines how the convergence and divergence of algorithmic and human-mediated processes in education could provide a critical lens for developing teachers' agency. The model is developed through a critical synthesis of existing research on AIED, teacher agency, and pedagogical practice.
Introduction
The rapid integration of Artificial Intelligence in Education (AIED) presents both opportunities and risks for pedagogical practice. The authors situate teachers' agency as a constituent element within the convergent and divergent dynamics at the intersection of human-mediated and algorithmically mediated pedagogies. They argue that while AI technologies can support pedagogical decision-making and meaning-making, there is a risk of pedagogical atrophy as human processes emulate and become increasingly dependent on AI. The paper aims to provide a critical lens for developing teachers' agency by examining these dynamics.
Why it matters
The authors discuss the implications of their model for teacher education and policy. They argue that the preparation of teachers should involve learning about the limitations and risks of AIED, as well as the potential. Strategies for developing teacher agency should include a critical understanding of the distinctive qualities of both human-mediated and algorithmically mediated pedagogy. Teacher education curricula and policy that develop understanding of a broad pedagogical repertoire is required for teachers to sustain a critical and professional stance in the context of AIED. The paper concludes by emphasizing the importance of teacher agency in navigating the convergence and divergence of human and algorithmic mediation in education.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ