Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Humaniora editorial

Open AccessOA2025

Administrative Justice in the Perspective of Islamic Legal Philosophy: A Comparative Study of Ethical Legitimacy and Bureaucratic Rationality

This study compares modern administrative law's reliance on Weberian bureaucratic rationality with Islamic legal philosophy's emphasis on ethical legitimacy and maqāṣid al-sharī‘ah. It argues that procedural legality alone cannot produce substantive justice without a moral-spiritual foundation.
S. Surahman; Abdurrahim Abdurrahim; Widyatmi Anandy; Fathul Hamdani; U. Nnawulezi· Jurnal Ilmiah Mizani Wacana Hukum Ekonomi Dan Keagamaan· 2025· DOI 10.29300/mzn.v12i2.8269

The core problem

The debate over justice in legal systems and public administration extends beyond normative-procedural aspects to encompass the moral, ethical, and spiritual dimensions of government practice. In the modern context, administrative law develops based on bureaucratic rationality as formulated by Max Weber, emphasizing procedural legality, efficiency, and institutional hierarchy as sources of legitimacy for state action. Within this paradigm, administrative justice is measured through adherence to written rules, procedural clarity, and impersonal administrative accountability mechanisms. However, despite guaranteeing order and efficiency, this system is often criticized for its tendency to ignore the moral substance and human values that are at the core of justice itself. Conversely, in Islamic legal philosophy, justice holds a higher and transcendental status. Justice is not merely the result of legal procedures but a manifestation of divine will ('adl) and an integral part of the objectives of Islamic law (maqāṣid al-sharī‘ah). Within this framework, bureaucratic actions—whether legislative, executive, or administrative—cannot be judged just solely because they conform to the rules; they must reflect ethical legitimacy, namely conformity to moral principles, honesty, social responsibility, and orientation toward the public good (maṣlaḥah ʿāmmah). Thus, legitimacy in Islamic law is moral-spiritual, not merely legal-formal. The gap between these two paradigms raises a fundamental question in the study of legal philosophy: is modern bureaucratic rationality capable of producing substantive justice, or does it require a deeper ethical foundation as offered by Islamic legal philosophy? In the context of public administration in Muslim countries, this question becomes increasingly relevant given the demand to integrate sharia values with the principles of efficient and transparent modern governance. Through this comparative study, the research aims to explore how Islamic legal philosophy interprets administrative justice and bureaucratic legitimacy from an ethical and theological perspective, and to identify fundamental differences between ethical legitimacy in Islamic law and bureaucratic rationality in modern administrative law. This approach is expected to provide a philosophical basis for the formation of a legal and bureaucratic system that is not only structurally rational but also morally and spiritually just.

Innovation

The study employs a comparative philosophical approach, analyzing primary texts of Islamic legal philosophy and modern administrative law theory. It examines the conceptual foundations of Weberian bureaucratic rationality and Islamic ethical legitimacy, drawing on the principles of maqāṣid al-sharī‘ah and the concept of 'adl. The comparative method is used to identify fundamental differences and potential points of integration between the two paradigms. The analysis focuses on the ethical and theological dimensions of administrative justice, assessing how each tradition justifies bureaucratic action and accountability. The research also considers the implications for public administration in Muslim countries, where demands for sharia compliance intersect with the need for efficient and transparent governance.
Introduction
The debate over justice in legal systems and public administration extends beyond normative-procedural aspects to encompass the moral, ethical, and spiritual dimensions of government practice. In the modern context, administrative law develops based on bureaucratic rationality as formulated by Max Weber, emphasizing procedural legality, efficiency, and institutional hierarchy as sources of legitimacy for state action. Within this paradigm, administrative justice is measured through adherence to written rules, procedural clarity, and impersonal administrative accountability mechanisms. However, despite guaranteeing order and efficiency, this system is often criticized for its tendency to ignore the moral substance and human values that are at the core of justice itself. Conversely, in Islamic legal philosophy, justice holds a higher and transcendental status. Justice is not merely the result of legal procedures but a manifestation of divine will ('adl) and an integral part of the objectives of Islamic law (maqāṣid al-sharī‘ah). Within this framework, bureaucratic actions—whether legislative, executive, or administrative—cannot be judged just solely because they conform to the rules; they must reflect ethical legitimacy, namely conformity to moral principles, honesty, social responsibility, and orientation toward the public good (maṣlaḥah ʿāmmah). Thus, legitimacy in Islamic law is moral-spiritual, not merely legal-formal. The gap between these two paradigms raises a fundamental question in the study of legal philosophy: is modern bureaucratic rationality capable of producing substantive justice, or does it require a deeper ethical foundation as offered by Islamic legal philosophy? In the context of public administration in Muslim countries, this question becomes increasingly relevant given the demand to integrate sharia values with the principles of efficient and transparent modern governance. Through this comparative study, the research aims to explore how Islamic legal philosophy interprets administrative justice and bureaucratic legitimacy from an ethical and theological perspective, and to identify fundamental differences between ethical legitimacy in Islamic law and bureaucratic rationality in modern administrative law. This approach is expected to provide a philosophical basis for the formation of a legal and bureaucratic system that is not only structurally rational but also morally and spiritually just.

Why it matters

The findings suggest that modern bureaucratic rationality alone is insufficient to achieve substantive justice, as it tends to reduce justice to rule-following and efficiency. This limitation is particularly problematic in Muslim countries, where there is a growing demand to integrate sharia values with modern governance principles. Islamic legal philosophy offers a robust ethical framework that can complement bureaucratic rationality by infusing administrative processes with moral and spiritual considerations. The concept of maṣlaḥah ʿāmmah, for instance, provides a criterion for evaluating bureaucratic actions beyond mere legality, ensuring that they serve the public interest and uphold human dignity. However, integrating these paradigms is not without challenges. It requires a reorientation of administrative ethics to incorporate theological and moral values, as well as a reinterpretation of bureaucratic rationality to accommodate ethical legitimacy. The study argues that a synthesis of Weberian rationality and Islamic ethical legitimacy can lead to a more holistic model of administrative justice—one that is both structurally rational and morally just. This model would be particularly relevant for legal and bureaucratic reforms in Muslim societies, where the call for sharia compliance must be balanced with the demands of efficient and transparent governance. The research concludes by proposing a philosophical basis for such a synthesis, emphasizing the need for a deeper ethical foundation in administrative law.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…