Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Fisika & Matematika editorial

Open AccessOA2025

Advances and Challenges of SCAN and r2SCAN Density Functionals in Transition‐Metal Compounds

This review examines the design principles, advancements, and remaining challenges of the SCAN and r2SCAN density functionals in describing transition-metal compounds, challenging the perception that Kohn-Sham DFT is inadequate for correlated systems.
Yu-Bo Zhang; Akilan Ramasamy; Kanun Pokharel; M. Kothakonda; Bing Xiao; J. Furness; Jin-Liang Ning; Rui-Qi Zhang; Jian-Wei Sun· WIREs Computational Molecular Science· 2025· DOI 10.1002/wcms.70007

The core problem

Transition-metal compounds (TMCs) with open-shell d-electrons exhibit a complex interplay of lattice, charge, orbital, and spin degrees of freedom, leading to exotic properties and applications. These systems are often classified as correlated due to strong inter-electronic interactions, commonly modeled with a Hubbard U parameter. Such complexity poses significant challenges to Kohn-Sham density functional theory (KS-DFT), the most widely used electronic structure method in condensed matter physics and materials science. While KS-DFT is formally exact for the ground-state total energy, its exchange-correlation energy must be approximated. The mean-field nature of KS implementations and limitations of current exchange-correlation density functional approximations have led to the perception that DFT is inadequate for correlated systems, particularly TMCs. Consequently, a common workaround is to augment DFT with an on-site Hubbard-like U correction. In recent years, the strongly constrained and appropriately normed (SCAN) density functional and its refined variant r2SCAN have achieved remarkable progress in accurately describing structural, energetic, electronic, magnetic, and vibrational properties of TMCs, challenging the traditional perception of DFT's limitations. This review explores the design principles of SCAN and r2SCAN, highlights their key advancements in studying TMCs, explains the mechanisms driving these improvements, and addresses remaining challenges.

Innovation

The review focuses on the SCAN and r2SCAN density functionals, which belong to the meta-GGA (generalized gradient approximation) class. SCAN is designed to satisfy all 17 known exact constraints that a meta-GGA can, using the kinetic energy density and its gradient as additional ingredients. It employs a dimensionless variable

to distinguish different bonding environments, where is the kinetic energy density, is the von Weizsäcker kinetic energy density, and is the uniform electron gas kinetic energy density. The exchange-correlation energy is expressed as:

SCAN's exchange functional interpolates between the single-orbital regime () and the slowly varying regime (), while the correlation functional includes a smooth cutoff to avoid double-counting. r2SCAN is a refined version that restores the correct fourth-order gradient expansion of the correlation energy and improves numerical stability, making it more suitable for solid-state calculations. The review analyzes benchmark studies of SCAN and r2SCAN for TMCs, comparing them with standard functionals like PBE and hybrid functionals, and discusses the role of the Hubbard U correction in conjunction with these functionals.

Introduction
Transition-metal compounds (TMCs) with open-shell d-electrons exhibit a complex interplay of lattice, charge, orbital, and spin degrees of freedom, leading to exotic properties and applications. These systems are often classified as correlated due to strong inter-electronic interactions, commonly modeled with a Hubbard U parameter. Such complexity poses significant challenges to Kohn-Sham density functional theory (KS-DFT), the most widely used electronic structure method in condensed matter physics and materials science. While KS-DFT is formally exact for the ground-state total energy, its exchange-correlation energy must be approximated. The mean-field nature of KS implementations and limitations of current exchange-correlation density functional approximations have led to the perception that DFT is inadequate for correlated systems, particularly TMCs. Consequently, a common workaround is to augment DFT with an on-site Hubbard-like U correction. In recent years, the strongly constrained and appropriately normed (SCAN) density functional and its refined variant r2SCAN have achieved remarkable progress in accurately describing structural, energetic, electronic, magnetic, and vibrational properties of TMCs, challenging the traditional perception of DFT's limitations. This review explores the design principles of SCAN and r2SCAN, highlights their key advancements in studying TMCs, explains the mechanisms driving these improvements, and addresses remaining challenges.

Why it matters

The mechanisms driving the improvements of SCAN and r2SCAN are attributed to their sophisticated functional forms that satisfy exact constraints and incorporate the kinetic energy density, allowing better differentiation of bonding environments. SCAN's ability to recognize different coordination and spin states leads to more accurate treatment of TMCs. However, challenges remain. The self-interaction error is not fully eliminated, and SCAN may still over-delocalize electrons in some cases. The choice of the Hubbard U parameter, when used, remains empirical and system-dependent. Additionally, SCAN's numerical stability issues, largely mitigated in r2SCAN, can affect convergence. The review discusses the importance of testing SCAN and r2SCAN across a diverse set of TMCs to identify systematic biases. Future directions include the development of SCAN-based hybrid functionals and the incorporation of long-range corrections. Overall, SCAN and r2SCAN represent significant advances in DFT for TMCs, but further refinements are needed to fully capture strong correlation effects without empirical parameters.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…