Ilmu Komputer & AI editorial
Open AccessOA2022
An Analysis of Retracted Papers in Computer Science
Analysis of the Retraction Watch database reveals that ~8% of retracted papers are in Computer Science, with 56% lacking clear reasons and continued citations post-retraction, impacting systematic reviews.
M. Shepperd; Leila Yousefiยท PLoS ONEยท 2022ยท DOI 10.1371/journal.pone.0285383
The core problem
Retraction of research papers is a growing phenomenon, yet information about retracted papers is distributed and inconsistent across publishers. This study aims to assess: (i) the extent and nature of retracted research in Computer Science (CS), (ii) the post-retraction citation behaviour of retracted works, and (iii) the potential impact upon systematic reviews and mapping studies. The authors analyze the Retraction Watch database and citation data from Web of Science and Google Scholar.
Innovation
The authors utilized the Retraction Watch database (as of 16 May 2022) containing 33,955 entries. They filtered entries classified as Computer Science and extracted citation information from Web of Science and Google Scholar to analyze post-retraction citations. The study also examined the reasons for retraction and the availability of versions beyond the Version of Record (VoR).
Introduction
Retraction of research papers is a growing phenomenon, yet information about retracted papers is distributed and inconsistent across publishers. This study aims to assess: (i) the extent and nature of retracted research in Computer Science (CS), (ii) the post-retraction citation behaviour of retracted works, and (iii) the potential impact upon systematic reviews and mapping studies. The authors analyze the Retraction Watch database and citation data from Web of Science and Google Scholar.
Why it matters
The findings indicate that retraction is a common outcome in CS, necessitating standardized procedures and taxonomies across publishers, as well as better research tools. The continued citation of retracted papers poses a risk of contaminating secondary analyses and meta-analyses. The authors recommend particular caution when undertaking such studies to avoid including problem primary studies.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ