Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholatโ€ฆ

Ilmu Sosial editorial

Open AccessOA2023

Anthropology Bright and Dark

Joel Robbins responds to Sherry Ortner's 'Dark Anthropology' by arguing that the study of ethics and the good, grounded in value pluralism, offers a more robust critical anthropology than a focus solely on neoliberal critique.
Joel Robbins; N. Langlitz; ร‰mir Mahieddin; Erica Weiss; C. Howland; Bruce Knauft; Cheryl Mattinglyยท Social Analysis: Journal of Cultural and Social Practiceยท 2023ยท DOI 10.3167/sa.2023.670403

The core problem

In her essay 'Dark Anthropology,' Sherry Ortner questions the critical potential of anthropological studies of ethics, particularly research focused on cultural articulations of the good. She advocates instead for the study of people's critiques of the neoliberal darkness that besets their lives. This article responds to Ortner's provocation by suggesting that critical, dark anthropology is handicapped by opposing itself to the study of the good. The author reconsiders the critical potential of the anthropological study of difference, arguing that this potential has been attenuated by relativism's focus on the negative sides of various cultural formations. Instead, an approach to difference based on value pluralism and its claims about the diversity of the good is proposed. The potential of the comparative study of the good is illustrated through contemporary research on prosperity gospel Christianity and recent work on hierarchy as a valued social form.

Innovation

This article is a theoretical and programmatic piece that engages in a critical review of Ortner's 'Dark Anthropology' and related literature. It draws on comparative ethnographic examples from diverse contexts, including prosperity gospel Christianity and studies of hierarchy, to substantiate its argument. The methodology is grounded in value pluralism, which posits that there are multiple, irreducible goods that cannot be ranked on a single scale. By examining how different cultural formations articulate and value these goods, the article demonstrates the critical potential of studying the good. The approach is not empirical in the sense of presenting new fieldwork but rather synthesizes existing anthropological research to make a case for a reoriented critical anthropology.
Introduction
In her essay 'Dark Anthropology,' Sherry Ortner questions the critical potential of anthropological studies of ethics, particularly research focused on cultural articulations of the good. She advocates instead for the study of people's critiques of the neoliberal darkness that besets their lives. This article responds to Ortner's provocation by suggesting that critical, dark anthropology is handicapped by opposing itself to the study of the good. The author reconsiders the critical potential of the anthropological study of difference, arguing that this potential has been attenuated by relativism's focus on the negative sides of various cultural formations. Instead, an approach to difference based on value pluralism and its claims about the diversity of the good is proposed. The potential of the comparative study of the good is illustrated through contemporary research on prosperity gospel Christianity and recent work on hierarchy as a valued social form.

Why it matters

The article argues that dark anthropology, by defining itself in opposition to the study of the good, inadvertently reinforces the very neoliberal logic it seeks to critique. Instead, a critical anthropology grounded in value pluralism can engage with the diversity of goods without reducing them to a single metric. This approach does not ignore suffering or injustice but situates them within a broader framework of value. The comparative study of the good thus offers a more nuanced and politically effective critique, as it takes seriously the aspirations and ethical commitments of the people anthropologists study. The author concludes by calling for a reorientation of critical anthropology towards the study of difference as a source of value, rather than as a site of darkness.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member contentโ€ฆ