Ilmu Sosial editorial
Open AccessOA2022
At the Edge of the Sensible: Cultivating Doubt in Radically Engaged Anthropology and Spirituality
Aja Smith argues that doubt, cultivated through radically engaged fieldwork with spiritual and mindfulness practitioners in Denmark, destabilizes both ontological certainty and the alleged analytical invalidity of engaged anthropology, making doubt a valuable anthropological disposition.
Aja Smithยท Ethos: Journal of the Society for Psychological Anthropologyยท 2022ยท DOI 10.1111/etho.12314
The core problem
Transformative experiences have long been a central interest for anthropologists studying spiritual phenomena. During fieldwork, many ethnographers have themselves undergone such experiences, caused by and fueling their confidence in radical participation as the soundest approach to understanding spiritual phenomena. These anthropologists inadvertently find themselves faced with the question of the ontological status of such phenomena, responses to which range from embracing them as ontologically real to steering clear of judgement. Arguments pertaining to the authority of the anthropologist follow a similar path, belief either framed as a precondition for understanding such matters or as undermining analytical validity. This article outlines a third position. Based upon radically engaged fieldwork conducted with people dedicated to spiritual and mindfulness-meditation training in Denmark, I explore doubt as a transformative experience. Doubt, I hold, destabilizes both ontological certainty and the alleged analytical invalidity of engaged anthropology, making doubt, I argue, a valuable anthropological disposition.
Innovation
The article draws on radically engaged fieldwork conducted with people dedicated to spiritual and mindfulness-meditation training in Denmark. The author adopts radical participation as the ethnographic approach, immersing herself in the practices and experiences of her interlocutors. This methodological stance places the ethnographer at the edge of the sensible, where transformative experiences may occur and where questions of ontological status and analytical authority become pressing. The fieldwork context is thus both the site of data collection and the ground on which the argument about doubt as a transformative experience is built.
Introduction
Transformative experiences have long been a central interest for anthropologists studying spiritual phenomena. During fieldwork, many ethnographers have themselves undergone such experiences, caused by and fueling their confidence in radical participation as the soundest approach to understanding spiritual phenomena. These anthropologists inadvertently find themselves faced with the question of the ontological status of such phenomena, responses to which range from embracing them as ontologically real to steering clear of judgement. Arguments pertaining to the authority of the anthropologist follow a similar path, belief either framed as a precondition for understanding such matters or as undermining analytical validity. This article outlines a third position. Based upon radically engaged fieldwork conducted with people dedicated to spiritual and mindfulness-meditation training in Denmark, I explore doubt as a transformative experience. Doubt, I hold, destabilizes both ontological certainty and the alleged analytical invalidity of engaged anthropology, making doubt, I argue, a valuable anthropological disposition.
Why it matters
The article argues that doubt destabilizes both ontological certainty and the alleged analytical invalidity of engaged anthropology. Rather than resolving the tension between belief and judgement, doubt holds it open, making doubt a valuable anthropological disposition. This third position moves beyond the binary of embracing spiritual phenomena as ontologically real or avoiding judgement altogether, and beyond the parallel binary of belief as precondition or as invalidity. By cultivating doubt as a transformative experience, the anthropologist can remain radically engaged while neither foreclosing ontological questions nor sacrificing analytical rigor. The argument thus contributes to debates on the authority of the anthropologist and the ontological status of spiritual phenomena, proposing doubt as a disposition that sustains both engagement and critique.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ