Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2023
Between Dialogue, Conflict, and Competition: The Limits of Responsive Judicial Review in the Case of the Romanian Constitutional Court
This article examines the applicability of Rosalind Dixon's responsive judicial review theory to the Romanian Constitutional Court, identifying three key shortcomings: formalist interpretation, weak rights review culture, and persistent conflict with other constitutional actors. It concludes by speculating on future developments that might make responsive judicial review more of a reality in Romanian constitutionalism.
S. Şuteu· Review of Central and Eastern European Law· 2023· DOI 10.1163/15730352-bja10092
The core problem
The article responds to Rosalind Dixon's *Responsive Judicial Review* (Oxford University Press 2023), which proposes a model of judicial review that is responsive to democratic dialogue and rights protection. The author, S. Șuteu, assesses the prospects and caveats of Dixon's theory in the specific context of the Romanian Constitutional Court. The central question is whether the Romanian Constitutional Court can serve as a responsive judicial review actor, engaging in dialogue with other branches and protecting rights effectively. The article argues that three important shortcomings limit the applicability of Dixon's framework in Romania: the tendency toward formalism in constitutional interpretation, an impoverished rights review culture, and the persistent conflictual positioning of the Constitutional Court vis-à-vis other constitutional actors.
Innovation
The analysis is based on a qualitative examination of recent case law from the Romanian Constitutional Court. The author applies Dixon's theoretical framework as a lens to evaluate the Court's jurisprudence, focusing on how the Court interprets the constitution, reviews rights claims, and interacts with other constitutional actors. The methodology involves a doctrinal analysis of selected decisions that illustrate the three identified shortcomings. The article also draws on secondary literature on Romanian constitutionalism and comparative judicial review to contextualize the findings.
Introduction
The article responds to Rosalind Dixon's *Responsive Judicial Review* (Oxford University Press 2023), which proposes a model of judicial review that is responsive to democratic dialogue and rights protection. The author, S. Șuteu, assesses the prospects and caveats of Dixon's theory in the specific context of the Romanian Constitutional Court. The central question is whether the Romanian Constitutional Court can serve as a responsive judicial review actor, engaging in dialogue with other branches and protecting rights effectively. The article argues that three important shortcomings limit the applicability of Dixon's framework in Romania: the tendency toward formalism in constitutional interpretation, an impoverished rights review culture, and the persistent conflictual positioning of the Constitutional Court vis-à-vis other constitutional actors.
Why it matters
The article discusses the implications of these findings for Dixon's theory. While responsive judicial review offers a normative ideal, the Romanian case demonstrates that institutional and cultural factors can significantly constrain its realization. The author argues that the three shortcomings are interconnected: formalism reinforces a weak rights culture, which in turn fuels conflict with other actors. However, the article also speculates on potential developments that could mitigate these limitations. For instance, changes in judicial appointment procedures, increased rights consciousness among judges, or external pressures from European institutions might gradually shift the Court's approach. The author concludes that responsive judicial review may become more of a reality in Romanian constitutionalism than present conditions allow, but only if these structural and cultural obstacles are addressed.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…