Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholatโ€ฆ

Ilmu Sosial editorial

Open AccessOA2025

Beyond Retraumatization: Trauma-Informed Political Science Research

This paper proposes a trauma-informed framework for political science research, distinguishing between less vulnerable and vulnerable contexts, and offers best practices for informed consent, debriefing, and addressing the special challenges of political violence research.
A. Weissยท British Journal of Political Scienceยท 2025ยท DOI 10.1017/S0007123424000620

The core problem

Ethics guidelines for political science instruct researchers to avoid retraumatization of human subjects (e.g., APSA 2022; Fujii 2012). Meanwhile, human subject research on sensitive topics, including violence and repression, has increased. This paper clarifies what is at stake when we talk about research participant distress and provides recommendations for handling concerns about trauma and retraumatization. It offers a new framework for trauma-informed political science research. The framework reflects conclusions from the empirical literature on the risk of distress in different research settings as well as critical normative perspectives on consequentialist research ethics. In particular, it identifies two approaches: one for research in less vulnerable contexts and one for research in contexts that are vulnerable in terms of limited resources, ongoing suffering, and/or geopolitical instability. The framework details best practices for informed consent, debriefing, and more within each approach. The paper also addresses the special challenges of political violence research. While the literature suggests that retraumatization as such is rarely a major risk of research, the paper highlights that a narrowly defined concept of retraumatization can lead us to neglect other trauma-informed concerns.

Innovation

The paper develops its framework through a synthesis of two strands of literature: empirical studies on the risk of distress in various research settings, and critical normative perspectives on consequentialist research ethics. It does not conduct new empirical research but rather reviews existing evidence to identify best practices. The framework is structured around two approaches: one for less vulnerable contexts and one for vulnerable contexts. For each approach, the paper details best practices for informed consent, debriefing, and other trauma-informed procedures. The paper also addresses the special challenges of political violence research, where participants may face ongoing risks. The methodology is thus conceptual and normative, aiming to provide practical guidance for researchers.
Introduction
Ethics guidelines for political science instruct researchers to avoid retraumatization of human subjects (e.g., APSA 2022; Fujii 2012). Meanwhile, human subject research on sensitive topics, including violence and repression, has increased. This paper clarifies what is at stake when we talk about research participant distress and provides recommendations for handling concerns about trauma and retraumatization. It offers a new framework for trauma-informed political science research. The framework reflects conclusions from the empirical literature on the risk of distress in different research settings as well as critical normative perspectives on consequentialist research ethics. In particular, it identifies two approaches: one for research in less vulnerable contexts and one for research in contexts that are vulnerable in terms of limited resources, ongoing suffering, and/or geopolitical instability. The framework details best practices for informed consent, debriefing, and more within each approach. The paper also addresses the special challenges of political violence research. While the literature suggests that retraumatization as such is rarely a major risk of research, the paper highlights that a narrowly defined concept of retraumatization can lead us to neglect other trauma-informed concerns.

Why it matters

The paper discusses the implications of its framework for political science research ethics. It argues that a consequentialist approach to ethics, which focuses on minimizing harm, is insufficient; instead, a trauma-informed approach that considers the broader context of participants' lives is necessary. The framework emphasizes the importance of informed consent as an ongoing process, debriefing that addresses participants' emotional needs, and training for researchers. The paper also calls for institutional review boards to adopt trauma-informed guidelines. It concludes that while retraumatization is a valid concern, it should not overshadow other ethical considerations, particularly in vulnerable contexts. The framework aims to help researchers navigate these complexities and conduct ethical research on sensitive topics.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member contentโ€ฆ