Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholatโ€ฆ

Hukum editorial

Open AccessOA2023

Beyond Rhetoric: Interrogating the Eurocentric Critique of International Criminal Lawโ€™s Selectivity in the Wake of the 2022 Ukraine Invasion

This article interrogates claims of Eurocentric bias in international criminal law following the 2022 Ukraine invasion, arguing that Ukraine's liminal status and the cross-border nature of aggression explain differentiated responses, and that the ICC's prior conflict with the African Union complicates accusations of an invidious 'Ukraine effect'.
Patryk I. Labudaยท Leiden Journal of International Lawยท 2023ยท DOI 10.1017/S0922156523000237

The core problem

Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 has reinvigorated debates over selectivity in international criminal law (ICL). The 'Ukraine moment' has been welcomed by many as a renewed push for accountability, but critics have highlighted double standards: Western violations often go unpunished, and European victims receive disproportionate attention. This article interrogates the master narratives about ICL's post-Ukraine selectivity. It complicates accusations of bias by emphasizing Ukraine's liminal status in the global order and the cross-border nature of aggression as explanatory factors for differentiated state responses. The author suggests that concerns about an invidious 'Ukraine effect' are less persuasive after the ICC's decade-long conflict with the African Union, and that decentring investigations to Eurasia should be seen not only as soul-searching but also as an opportunity to rebalance the scales of justice. The article encourages ICL stakeholders to move beyond critique that unwittingly essentializes Eurocentric assumptions and to devise a more compelling vision of global criminal law enforcement that challenges crimes and inequalities both between and within states.

Innovation

The article employs a doctrinal and critical analysis of international criminal law, focusing on the discourse surrounding selectivity in the wake of the 2022 Ukraine invasion. It examines master narratives about ICL's selectivity, drawing on legal scholarship, policy statements, and institutional practices. The analysis is situated within the broader context of the ICC's relationship with the African Union and the concept of liminality in global order. The author engages with critiques of Eurocentrism and develops a nuanced argument that challenges both uncritical celebrations and sweeping condemnations of the 'Ukraine moment'. The methodology is qualitative, interpretive, and grounded in international legal theory.
Introduction
Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 has reinvigorated debates over selectivity in international criminal law (ICL). The 'Ukraine moment' has been welcomed by many as a renewed push for accountability, but critics have highlighted double standards: Western violations often go unpunished, and European victims receive disproportionate attention. This article interrogates the master narratives about ICL's post-Ukraine selectivity. It complicates accusations of bias by emphasizing Ukraine's liminal status in the global order and the cross-border nature of aggression as explanatory factors for differentiated state responses. The author suggests that concerns about an invidious 'Ukraine effect' are less persuasive after the ICC's decade-long conflict with the African Union, and that decentring investigations to Eurasia should be seen not only as soul-searching but also as an opportunity to rebalance the scales of justice. The article encourages ICL stakeholders to move beyond critique that unwittingly essentializes Eurocentric assumptions and to devise a more compelling vision of global criminal law enforcement that challenges crimes and inequalities both between and within states.

Why it matters

The article critically examines the master narratives about ICL's selectivity post-Ukraine. It argues that the focus on Eurocentrism often overlooks the complex reasons behind differentiated responses, including Ukraine's liminality and the nature of aggression. The author contends that the ICC's prior engagements with the African Union have already shaped a more nuanced understanding of selectivity, and thus the 'Ukraine effect' is not as invidious as some suggest. Instead, the shift toward Eurasia should be viewed as an opportunity to address historical imbalances. The discussion encourages stakeholders to move beyond rhetoric and develop a vision of global criminal law enforcement that challenges crimes and inequalities both between and within states. This requires a reflexive approach that avoids essentializing Eurocentric assumptions while acknowledging the persistent structural biases in international justice.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member contentโ€ฆ