Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Ekonomi & Bisnis editorial

Open AccessOA2023

Board Characteristics and the Likelihood of Financial Statements Fraud: Empirical Evidence from an Emerging Market

This study investigates how board characteristics—independence, size, meeting frequency, and gender diversity—affect the likelihood of financial statement fraud in Saudi Arabia. Using data from 67 firms over 2014–2019 and the modified Beneish M-score, it finds that board independence significantly reduces fraud risk, while larger boards increase it.
Ibrahim El-Sayed Ebaid· Future Business Journal· 2023· DOI 10.1186/s43093-023-00218-z

The core problem

Financial statements are the primary source of information about a company, especially in emerging markets like the Saudi Stock Exchange, where alternative information channels are limited. Fraudulent financial reporting undermines investor confidence and market efficiency, making it crucial to identify governance mechanisms that can curb such practices. This study focuses on the board of directors, a key internal governance mechanism, and examines how four board characteristics—independence, size, meeting frequency, and gender diversity—influence the likelihood of financial statement fraud. The research is set in Saudi Arabia, an emerging market with a unique institutional context, and aims to provide empirical evidence on the effectiveness of board attributes in mitigating fraud.

Innovation

The study uses a sample of 67 companies listed on the Saudi Stock Exchange (Tadawul) over a six-year period from 2014 to 2019, resulting in 402 firm-year observations. Financial statement fraud is measured using the modified Beneish M-score model (Beneish, 1999), which identifies earnings manipulation through eight financial ratios. The model computes an M-score for each firm-year; firms with an M-score greater than -1.78 are classified as likely manipulators. The four board characteristics are measured as follows: board independence (proportion of independent directors), board size (total number of directors), meeting frequency (number of board meetings per year), and gender diversity (proportion of female directors). Panel data techniques, specifically fixed-effects and random-effects models, are employed to examine the relationship between these board characteristics and the likelihood of fraud, controlling for firm size, leverage, and profitability.
Introduction
Financial statements are the primary source of information about a company, especially in emerging markets like the Saudi Stock Exchange, where alternative information channels are limited. Fraudulent financial reporting undermines investor confidence and market efficiency, making it crucial to identify governance mechanisms that can curb such practices. This study focuses on the board of directors, a key internal governance mechanism, and examines how four board characteristics—independence, size, meeting frequency, and gender diversity—influence the likelihood of financial statement fraud. The research is set in Saudi Arabia, an emerging market with a unique institutional context, and aims to provide empirical evidence on the effectiveness of board attributes in mitigating fraud.

Why it matters

The findings underscore the importance of board independence as a deterrent to financial statement fraud in emerging markets. Independent directors bring objectivity and oversight, aligning with agency theory predictions. However, the positive effect of board size suggests that beyond a certain point, larger boards may suffer from inefficiencies, such as diffusion of responsibility and communication breakdowns, which can weaken monitoring. The lack of significance for gender diversity and meeting frequency may be attributed to the Saudi context, where female representation on boards is still relatively low and board meetings may be more ceremonial than substantive. The study contributes to the corporate governance literature by providing evidence from an under-researched market and offers practical implications for regulators and policymakers aiming to strengthen governance frameworks to combat fraud.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…