Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholatโ€ฆ

Hukum editorial

Open AccessOA2024

Border Carbon Adjustment Compliance and the WTO: The Interactional Evolution of Law

This paper applies an interactional international law framework and discourse network analysis to show that the EU's view of border carbon adjustments as WTO-compliant evolved through changing actor perceptions and expanded legality practices, not formal WTO rule changes.
Laurie Durelยท Journal of international economic lawยท 2024ยท DOI 10.1093/jiel/jgae007

The core problem

The paper addresses the puzzle of how international legal understanding can evolve outside of formal treaty amendments. It focuses on the debate over the compatibility of border carbon adjustment (BCA) measures with World Trade Organization (WTO) rules. The central argument is that international law depends on actors' perceptions, which can change over time. The study examines how a policy once widely deemed incompatible with WTO rules has come to be considered 'WTO-compliant' by the European Union. The research question is: what elements explain this shift in legal understanding in the absence of significant changes in WTO case law? The paper contributes to scholarship on the dynamics of international law by offering a framework to trace the evolution of legal understanding through formal and informal processes.

Innovation

The study employs an interactional international law framework combined with discourse network analysis. The dataset comprises debates from the WTO and the legal literature spanning 24 years. Discourse network analysis is used to map the evolution of actors' perceptions and the structure of the debate over time. The method allows the authors to trace changes in the confidence of legal scholars regarding BCAโ€“WTO compatibility. The analysis focuses on the period since 2012, when the legal literature increasingly expressed confidence that BCA could be WTO-compatible. The paper also examines the role of expanded practice of legality and perceived lack of legality of applicable WTO rules as sustaining factors for this shift.
Introduction
The paper addresses the puzzle of how international legal understanding can evolve outside of formal treaty amendments. It focuses on the debate over the compatibility of border carbon adjustment (BCA) measures with World Trade Organization (WTO) rules. The central argument is that international law depends on actors' perceptions, which can change over time. The study examines how a policy once widely deemed incompatible with WTO rules has come to be considered 'WTO-compliant' by the European Union. The research question is: what elements explain this shift in legal understanding in the absence of significant changes in WTO case law? The paper contributes to scholarship on the dynamics of international law by offering a framework to trace the evolution of legal understanding through formal and informal processes.

Why it matters

The paper argues that the interactional international law framework explains how perceptions of legality can change over time, leading to a reinterpretation of compatibility. The expanded practice of legality refers to the growing acceptance of certain policy measures through repeated interactions and discourse, even without formal adjudication. The perceived lack of legality of applicable WTO rules suggests that actors may view existing rules as ambiguous or outdated, creating space for new interpretations. This research offers new insights into the dynamics of international law and provides methodological avenues for scholars seeking to trace the evolution of law and legal understanding through formal and informal processes. The implications extend to other areas where legal compatibility is contested and where perceptions play a crucial role.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member contentโ€ฆ