Ekonomi & Bisnis editorial
Open AccessOA2023
Bringing Household Finance Back In: House Prices and the Missing Macroeconomics of Comparative Political Economy
Wood and Stockhammer argue that comparative political economy has overlooked household finance. Using data from 18 advanced economies (1980โ2019), they show that house price inflation drives household debt, which in turn fuels GDP growth, while business debt has negative growth effects.
James D. G. Wood; Engelbert Stockhammerยท Politics & Societyยท 2023ยท DOI 10.1177/00323292231201480
The core problem
The article addresses a significant gap in the comparative political economy (CPE) literature: the macroeconomic role of household finance. While existing frameworks such as varieties of capitalism (VoC) and growth models approaches have focused predominantly on corporate finance and business debt, the authors contend that this focus is misplaced. Drawing on post-Keynesian theories of finance and the financialization literature, they argue that house prices and mortgage credit are central to the macroeconomy. Specifically, speculative house price cycles can facilitate homeowner consumption through equity release mortgages, thereby linking housing markets to aggregate demand and growth. The authors set out to demonstrate that household debt dynamics are determined by house price inflation and that rising household debt contributes positively to GDP growth, whereas business debt has negative growth effects. This challenges conventional wisdom and calls for a reorientation of CPE theory.
Innovation
The authors employ an econometric evaluation of eighteen advanced economies over the period 1980 to 2019. The dataset includes measures of household debt, business debt, house price inflation, and GDP growth, among other variables. The empirical strategy likely involves panel data techniques to account for cross-country heterogeneity and time-series dynamics. The analysis tests the hypotheses that house price inflation drives household debt and that household debt growth stimulates GDP growth, while business debt growth may have contractionary effects. The robustness of results is checked across countries with different growth models and financial systems, ensuring that findings are not driven by specific institutional configurations. The methodology integrates insights from post-Keynesian economics, which emphasizes the role of finance and demand, with the comparative political economy tradition that seeks to understand institutional variation across advanced economies.
Introduction
The article addresses a significant gap in the comparative political economy (CPE) literature: the macroeconomic role of household finance. While existing frameworks such as varieties of capitalism (VoC) and growth models approaches have focused predominantly on corporate finance and business debt, the authors contend that this focus is misplaced. Drawing on post-Keynesian theories of finance and the financialization literature, they argue that house prices and mortgage credit are central to the macroeconomy. Specifically, speculative house price cycles can facilitate homeowner consumption through equity release mortgages, thereby linking housing markets to aggregate demand and growth. The authors set out to demonstrate that household debt dynamics are determined by house price inflation and that rising household debt contributes positively to GDP growth, whereas business debt has negative growth effects. This challenges conventional wisdom and calls for a reorientation of CPE theory.
Why it matters
The authors interpret their findings as evidence that comparative political economy has missed a crucial dimension of macroeconomic dynamics: household finance. The varieties of capitalism framework, with its focus on corporate governance and business finance, fails to capture the demand-side effects of housing wealth and mortgage credit. Similarly, the growth models approach, while more attentive to demand, lacks a theory of house prices and financial cycles. The authors propose that speculative house price cycles can generate debt-driven growth, but such growth is inherently fragile, as it relies on continuously rising house prices and increasing indebtedness. This has implications for understanding financial stability and the sustainability of growth regimes. The study calls for integrating household finance into CPE theories, recognizing that housing markets and mortgage credit are not merely epiphenomenal but central to the macroeconomy. The findings also suggest that policy should monitor household debt and house price dynamics to prevent boom-bust cycles.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ