Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Humaniora editorial

Open AccessOA2025

«Civilizational Renaissance» and Sociocultural Economics

The article examines the epistemological problems of the domestic version of socio-cultural economics as a subject of intellectual history, analyzed in the context of the civilizational renaissance developing since the 2010s. It argues that overcoming these difficulties requires a more active integration into the civilizational renaissance, a greater role for humanitarian aspects, and a move toward a transdisciplinary, multiperspectivist, constructivist approach.
I. Ionov· Issues of Economic Theory· 2025· DOI 10.52342/2587-7666vte_2025_2_55_70

The core problem

The article addresses the epistemological problems of the domestic version of socio-cultural economics as a subject of intellectual history, situated within the context of the civilizational renaissance that has been developing since the 2010s. It is shown that socio-cultural economics is associated with the processes of deglobalization and the undermining of traditional ideas about modernization. These trends are most clearly manifested in sociology, where the civilizational turn determined the idea of Modernity as a new type of civilization, and the idea of the plurality of modernities, including alternative and intertwined ones. The author, I. Ionov, sets out to analyze how socio-cultural economics has manifested features of the civilizational renaissance—such as the contingency of the narrative, attention to alternative versions of explanations, the desire to think "from the contrary", and features of cultural, spatial, and historical turns common to social and humanitarian knowledge—while also identifying its detachment from the centuries-old tradition of civilizational analysis and a number of its disciplinary areas.

Innovation

The study employs an epistemological and intellectual-historical analysis of the domestic version of socio-cultural economics. It examines the cross-cutting connection with S. Huntington's position, which leads to an increased influence of classical scientific knowledge and a metahistorical approach to civilizational analysis associated with scientism, determinism, and essentialism. This is manifested in ignoring a number of alternative versions of the interpretation of socio-cultural influences on the economy, and problems with the use of the concept of a cultural code. The methodological approach is thus critical and reflexive, aiming to uncover the epistemological assumptions and limitations of the current paradigm. The author draws on the broader context of the civilizational turn in social and humanitarian knowledge, including the ideas of multiple modernities and alternative modernities, to frame the analysis.
Introduction
The article addresses the epistemological problems of the domestic version of socio-cultural economics as a subject of intellectual history, situated within the context of the civilizational renaissance that has been developing since the 2010s. It is shown that socio-cultural economics is associated with the processes of deglobalization and the undermining of traditional ideas about modernization. These trends are most clearly manifested in sociology, where the civilizational turn determined the idea of Modernity as a new type of civilization, and the idea of the plurality of modernities, including alternative and intertwined ones. The author, I. Ionov, sets out to analyze how socio-cultural economics has manifested features of the civilizational renaissance—such as the contingency of the narrative, attention to alternative versions of explanations, the desire to think "from the contrary", and features of cultural, spatial, and historical turns common to social and humanitarian knowledge—while also identifying its detachment from the centuries-old tradition of civilizational analysis and a number of its disciplinary areas.

Why it matters

Overcoming these difficulties is seen in a more active integration of socio-cultural economics into the process of civilizational renaissance, an increasing role for humanitarian aspects of analysis, and a movement toward a transdisciplinary, multiperspectivist, constructivist approach that expands the cognitive maps of economists by reframing civilizational models. The author argues that the current reliance on Huntingtonian categories and scientistic metahistorical approaches limits the explanatory power of socio-cultural economics, as it ignores alternative interpretations of how culture and civilization influence economic processes. The concept of a cultural code, in particular, is problematic when used without sufficient reflexivity. A transdisciplinary and constructivist turn would allow economists to incorporate insights from sociology, history, and cultural studies, and to recognize the plurality of modernities and civilizational trajectories. This would also align socio-cultural economics more closely with the broader civilizational renaissance, which emphasizes contingency, alternative explanations, and a critical stance toward linear modernization narratives.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…