Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholatโ€ฆ

Ekonomi & Bisnis editorial

Open AccessOA2023

Complexity Defying Macroeconomics

Pablo Paniagua explores the tension between complex phenomena and macroeconomic models, arguing that Hayek's notion of organised complexity reveals fundamental flaws in standard reductionist approaches and calls for alternative strategies that account for emergent totality and causal structures.
Pablo Paniaguaยท Cambridge Journal of Economicsยท 2023ยท DOI 10.1093/cje/bead002

The core problem

The article addresses the intersection of complexity and macroeconomics, questioning whether contemporary macroeconomic models can adequately capture complex phenomena. Paniagua draws on F. A. Hayek's concept of organised complexity to examine the causal properties that challenge the analytical criteria and assumptions of modern macro. The central problem is that standard models rely on radical reductionism and formalistic methods that fail to account for the macroeconomy as an emergent totality arising from the interplay between individuals and organising structures. The purpose is twofold: first, to associate complexity properties with the idea of the macroeconomy as an emergent totality, thereby framing analytical tensions; second, to suggest that introducing complexity facilitates breaking away from current straitjackets and requires alternative strategies sensitive to rules, structures, and causal properties.

Innovation

This is a conceptual and theoretical paper. The methodology involves a critical evaluation of the properties of organised complexity as articulated by Hayek, and an assessment of how these properties relate to the assumptions and analytical criteria used in contemporary macroeconomic models. The approach is comparative and analytical, contrasting the causal properties of complex systems with the reductionist and formalistic foundations of standard macro. No empirical data or formal modeling is employed; instead, the argument proceeds through logical exposition and conceptual analysis, drawing on the literature on complexity and macroeconomics.
Introduction
The article addresses the intersection of complexity and macroeconomics, questioning whether contemporary macroeconomic models can adequately capture complex phenomena. Paniagua draws on F. A. Hayek's concept of organised complexity to examine the causal properties that challenge the analytical criteria and assumptions of modern macro. The central problem is that standard models rely on radical reductionism and formalistic methods that fail to account for the macroeconomy as an emergent totality arising from the interplay between individuals and organising structures. The purpose is twofold: first, to associate complexity properties with the idea of the macroeconomy as an emergent totality, thereby framing analytical tensions; second, to suggest that introducing complexity facilitates breaking away from current straitjackets and requires alternative strategies sensitive to rules, structures, and causal properties.

Why it matters

Paniagua argues that the recognition of complexity necessitates a methodological shift in macroeconomics. Instead of adhering to formalistic methods and radical reductionism, economists should adopt unconventional strategies that are sensitive to the causal properties of organised complexity. This means moving away from closed-form models and embracing approaches that can handle open systems, emergent phenomena, and the role of rules and structures. The paper suggests that such a shift would allow for a more realistic analysis of the macroeconomy as an emergent totality. The discussion also highlights the limitations of current models in addressing real-world complexities, such as financial crises and structural change. The author calls for a pluralistic approach that incorporates insights from complexity science and institutional economics, among others.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member contentโ€ฆ