Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2025
Constitutional Implications of Constitutional Court Decision No. 105/PUU-XXII/2024 on Freedom of Expression and Defamation in Indonesia
This study analyzes Constitutional Court Decision No. 105/PUU-XXII/2024, which restricts defamation under the UU ITE to natural persons and requires tangible harm for hoax-related liability, reinforcing legality, proportionality, and legal certainty. It argues for harmonizing the UU ITE with the new Criminal Code to prevent arbitrary criminalization of public expression.
Pipit Somefotorono Majid; Besse Sari Angraeniยท Constitutional Law Reviewยท 2025ยท DOI 10.30863/clr.v4i2.5951
The core problem
The study examines the constitutional implications of Constitutional Court Decision No. 105/PUU-XXII/2024 on Indonesia's digital criminal law system, focusing on the interpretation of defamation and hoax provisions in the Electronic Information and Transactions Law (UU ITE). The research addresses the urgency of harmonizing the UU ITE with the new Criminal Code (KUHP) to safeguard freedom of expression. The central problem is the potential for arbitrary criminalization of public expression through ambiguous terms such as "other person" in Articles 27A and 45 of the UU ITE, and the material offense principle in Article 28 regarding the dissemination of false information ("hoaxes"). The study aims to analyze the Court's interpretation and its implications for the principles of legality, proportionality, and legal certainty, and to formulate a framework for digital criminal law that balances individual reputation protection with constitutionally protected freedom of expression.
Innovation
The research employs a normative (doctrinal) legal methodology with statutory, case, and conceptual approaches. The analysis draws on positive legal norms, judicial decisions, academic literature, and reports from digital rights monitoring organizations. The focus is on the Constitutional Court's interpretation of the term "other person" in Articles 27A and 45 of the UU ITE and the material offense principle in the dissemination of false information under Article 28 of the UU ITE. The doctrinal approach involves a systematic analysis of legal texts and their interpretation by the Court, supplemented by case law and scholarly commentary. The inclusion of reports from digital rights monitoring organizations provides empirical context regarding the impact of these provisions on freedom of expression.
Introduction
The study examines the constitutional implications of Constitutional Court Decision No. 105/PUU-XXII/2024 on Indonesia's digital criminal law system, focusing on the interpretation of defamation and hoax provisions in the Electronic Information and Transactions Law (UU ITE). The research addresses the urgency of harmonizing the UU ITE with the new Criminal Code (KUHP) to safeguard freedom of expression. The central problem is the potential for arbitrary criminalization of public expression through ambiguous terms such as "other person" in Articles 27A and 45 of the UU ITE, and the material offense principle in Article 28 regarding the dissemination of false information ("hoaxes"). The study aims to analyze the Court's interpretation and its implications for the principles of legality, proportionality, and legal certainty, and to formulate a framework for digital criminal law that balances individual reputation protection with constitutionally protected freedom of expression.
Why it matters
The study underscores the necessity of harmonizing the UU ITE with the new KUHP and other criminal regulations to prevent arbitrary criminalization of public expression. The Court's interpretation of "other person" as limited to natural persons reflects a commitment to legal certainty and proportionality, ensuring that defamation laws are not used to stifle legitimate criticism or debate. The requirement of tangible harm for hoax-related liability introduces a material offense principle that aligns with the KUHP's emphasis on actual harm rather than mere dissemination. This approach balances the protection of individual reputation with the constitutional guarantee of freedom of expression. The scholarly contribution lies in formulating a framework for digital criminal law that integrates these principles, providing an analytical perspective on constitutional interpretation mechanisms in addressing the challenges of digital regulation. The study also highlights the role of digital rights monitoring organizations in documenting the impact of criminal provisions on public expression, suggesting that future legislative reforms should incorporate such empirical insights to ensure that digital laws are both effective and rights-respecting.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ