Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2024
Contemplating Maritime Autonomous Surface Ships (MASS) under the international law on ship-source pollution
This digest examines the legal challenges posed by Maritime Autonomous Surface Ships (MASS) under international ship-source pollution law, highlighting uncertainties in prevention, combating, and compensation regimes.
Wangwang Xingยท Marine Pollution Bulletinยท 2024ยท DOI 10.1016/j.marpolbul.2024.116884
The core problem
Autonomous ships are increasingly viewed as the next generation of vessels capable of meeting sustainability challenges in the maritime industry. While numerous studies have highlighted their potential to be emission-free and reduce air pollution, research has paid scant attention to the significant uncertainties associated with autonomous shipping that may lead to new environmental risks, such as traffic incidents and oil spills. This paper addresses this gap by assessing the compatibility of autonomous ships with international environmental laws and regulations. The author proposes an analytical framework of international law on ship-source pollution to contemplate such a legal assessment. The central argument is that autonomous ships would challenge relevant treaty provisions on preventing, combating, and compensating for ship-source pollution, raising a number of new legal issues and resulting in a current lack of legal predictability and certainty. Only as autonomous ships become more widely tested, recognised, and trusted will a robust roadmap for legalising MASS become clearer.
Innovation
The paper employs a doctrinal legal research methodology, analysing international treaty provisions related to ship-source pollution. The author develops an analytical framework that categorises international law on ship-source pollution into three key areas: prevention, combating, and compensation. This framework is then applied to assess the compatibility of autonomous ships with existing legal instruments. The analysis focuses on identifying legal gaps and uncertainties that arise when autonomous technologies are integrated into the maritime regulatory landscape. The methodology involves a systematic review of relevant international conventions and their provisions, examining how these provisions might be challenged by the operation of MASS. The author does not conduct empirical testing but rather provides a conceptual legal analysis based on existing legal texts and secondary literature.
Introduction
Autonomous ships are increasingly viewed as the next generation of vessels capable of meeting sustainability challenges in the maritime industry. While numerous studies have highlighted their potential to be emission-free and reduce air pollution, research has paid scant attention to the significant uncertainties associated with autonomous shipping that may lead to new environmental risks, such as traffic incidents and oil spills. This paper addresses this gap by assessing the compatibility of autonomous ships with international environmental laws and regulations. The author proposes an analytical framework of international law on ship-source pollution to contemplate such a legal assessment. The central argument is that autonomous ships would challenge relevant treaty provisions on preventing, combating, and compensating for ship-source pollution, raising a number of new legal issues and resulting in a current lack of legal predictability and certainty. Only as autonomous ships become more widely tested, recognised, and trusted will a robust roadmap for legalising MASS become clearer.
Why it matters
The paper discusses the implications of these findings for the future of autonomous shipping. It argues that the legal uncertainties identified could hinder the development and deployment of MASS, as stakeholders may be reluctant to invest in technology that operates in a regulatory grey area. The author suggests that a robust roadmap for legalising MASS will emerge only as the technology becomes more widely tested, recognised, and trusted. This implies a gradual, iterative approach to legal reform, where international regulations are adapted in response to practical experience and technological advancements. The discussion also highlights the need for a multi-stakeholder approach involving governments, industry, and international organisations to address the legal challenges. The paper concludes by emphasising the importance of proactive legal analysis to ensure that environmental protection keeps pace with technological innovation in the maritime sector.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ