Ilmu Sosial editorial
Open AccessOA2019
Contemporary Historiography on the Phenomenon of Social Cohesion During the Second World War
This article reviews contemporary British, German, and Russian historiography on social cohesion in the USSR, Great Britain, and Germany during World War II, finding shared interest in personalities, everyday life, and gender but insufficient direct analysis of cohesion itself.
Людмила Владимировна Алиева; L. Antonova; T. Khrishkevich· Journal of the Belarusian State University. History· 2019· DOI 10.33581/2520-6338-2019-4-7-16
The core problem
The historiography of World War II is one of the most extensive research topics in historical science. Over the years, a comprehensive study of the military, political and economic history of wartime has been conducted. Particular attention during recent decades has been given to the social aspects of the war. However, the topic of social cohesion in the warring countries remains insufficiently analyzed. Thus, the main objective of the article is to analyze the current state of research on social cohesion in the context of World War II in contemporary British, German and Russian historical literature. The authors frame the problem around three national cases—the Soviet Union, Great Britain and Germany—and ask how far existing scholarship has addressed the phenomenon of social cohesion under wartime conditions.
Innovation
The present study of the reflection of cohesion problems in the Soviet Union, Great Britain and Germany during World War II is based on the principles of a new interdisciplinary branch of social science – anthropology of war. This approach integrates the achievements, subject areas and research tools of history, sociology, military psychology, cultural studies, pedagogy, medicine and other disciplines that study the existence of people and society at large in wartime conditions. The authors conduct a comparative analysis of the selected British, German and Russian historiography, examining commonalities and differences in approaches, assessments and methods.
Introduction
The historiography of World War II is one of the most extensive research topics in historical science. Over the years, a comprehensive study of the military, political and economic history of wartime has been conducted. Particular attention during recent decades has been given to the social aspects of the war. However, the topic of social cohesion in the warring countries remains insufficiently analyzed. Thus, the main objective of the article is to analyze the current state of research on social cohesion in the context of World War II in contemporary British, German and Russian historical literature. The authors frame the problem around three national cases—the Soviet Union, Great Britain and Germany—and ask how far existing scholarship has addressed the phenomenon of social cohesion under wartime conditions.
Why it matters
The differences in assessments and methods are determined by the role and place of a particular state in the military-political confrontation as well as by prevailing historiographical paradigms. In any case, the theme of social cohesion was not adequately reflected in these studies. The authors conclude by noting the research potential of analyzing the problems of social cohesion during World War II, suggesting that the anthropology of war offers a productive framework for future work that places cohesion at the center of inquiry rather than treating it as a byproduct of other social histories.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…