Ekonomi & Bisnis editorial
Open AccessOA2025
Convergence? Thoughts about the Evolution of Mainstream Macroeconomics over the Last 40 Years
Olivier Blanchard reviews 40 years of mainstream macroeconomics, arguing that the field has substantially converged in methodology, architecture, and mechanisms, and that this convergence has been largely beneficial. He also cautions against an overemphasis on general equilibrium from the outset.
O. Blanchard· Social Science Research Network· 2025· DOI 10.2139/ssrn.5255713
The core problem
This year marks the 40th anniversary of the NBER Macro Annual Conference, founded in 1986. The paper reviews the evolution of mainstream macroeconomics since then, presenting the author's views informed by a survey of researchers who have made important contributions to the field. Two main arguments are developed. First, starting from strikingly different positions, there has been substantial convergence in terms of methodology, architecture, and main mechanisms. Second, this convergence has been, for the most part, good convergence—the creation of a generally accepted conceptual and analytical structure, a core to which additional distortions can be added, allowing for discussions and integration of new ideas and evidence, rather than fights about basic methodology. However, not everything is right: there is too much emphasis on general equilibrium implications from the start, rather than first on partial equilibrium analysis of the phenomenon at hand. The appendix gives a sample of the views of the survey members on each of these arguments.
Innovation
The paper identifies three dimensions of convergence. In terms of methodology, there is now explicit micro foundations and explicit treatment of distortions, with, at the same time, an increased willingness to deviate from rational expectations, neoclassical utility and profit maximization. This represents a significant shift from earlier approaches that either lacked micro foundations or adhered strictly to rational expectations and neoclassical assumptions. The convergence allows for a more flexible and realistic modeling of economic behavior while maintaining analytical rigor.
Introduction
This year marks the 40th anniversary of the NBER Macro Annual Conference, founded in 1986. The paper reviews the evolution of mainstream macroeconomics since then, presenting the author's views informed by a survey of researchers who have made important contributions to the field. Two main arguments are developed. First, starting from strikingly different positions, there has been substantial convergence in terms of methodology, architecture, and main mechanisms. Second, this convergence has been, for the most part, good convergence—the creation of a generally accepted conceptual and analytical structure, a core to which additional distortions can be added, allowing for discussions and integration of new ideas and evidence, rather than fights about basic methodology. However, not everything is right: there is too much emphasis on general equilibrium implications from the start, rather than first on partial equilibrium analysis of the phenomenon at hand. The appendix gives a sample of the views of the survey members on each of these arguments.
Why it matters
The paper argues that the convergence has been beneficial, creating a generally accepted conceptual and analytical structure—a core to which additional distortions can be added. This core facilitates discussions and integration of new ideas and evidence, rather than fights about basic methodology. However, the author criticizes the excessive emphasis on general equilibrium implications from the start, rather than first focusing on partial equilibrium analysis of the phenomenon at hand. This critique suggests that the field might benefit from a more incremental approach, analyzing specific phenomena in isolation before embedding them in full general equilibrium models. The appendix provides a sample of survey members' views on each of these arguments, offering a range of perspectives on the convergence narrative.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…