Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2023
Corporate Criminal Liability on Environmental Law: Indonesia and Australia
This paper examines Indonesia's corporate criminal liability regime for environmental law violations, exploring underlying doctrines, triggering actions, attribution mechanisms, and trial procedures, with comparative reference to Australia.
Muhammad Aditya Wijaya; Alif Imam Dzakiยท Mulawarman law reviewยท 2023ยท DOI 10.30872/mulrev.v8i2.1306
The core problem
Environmental damage is a pressing issue in Indonesia, largely attributed to the activities of large corporations. To address this, corporate criminal liability has been adopted as a measure to hold companies accountable for environmental law violations. This paper by Muhammad Aditya Wijaya and Alif Imam Dzaki, published in Mulawarman Law Review, aims to discuss and analyze the legal regulation system of corporate criminal liability in Indonesia. It delves into the nature of corporate criminal responsibility, the doctrines underlying it, actions triggering liability, attribution of responsibility to corporations, and trial procedures within the Indonesian judicial system. The paper also makes comparative references to Australia, providing a broader perspective on how different jurisdictions handle corporate environmental crimes.
Innovation
The paper employs a normative legal research methodology, analyzing primary legal sources such as statutes and regulations, as well as secondary sources including legal doctrines and comparative law materials. The focus is on the Indonesian legal framework, with comparative insights drawn from Australian law to highlight similarities and differences in corporate criminal liability for environmental offenses. The analysis is structured around key aspects: the doctrinal foundations of corporate criminal responsibility, the types of actions that trigger liability, the mechanisms for attributing criminal responsibility to corporations, and the procedural aspects of trying corporations in court.
Introduction
Environmental damage is a pressing issue in Indonesia, largely attributed to the activities of large corporations. To address this, corporate criminal liability has been adopted as a measure to hold companies accountable for environmental law violations. This paper by Muhammad Aditya Wijaya and Alif Imam Dzaki, published in Mulawarman Law Review, aims to discuss and analyze the legal regulation system of corporate criminal liability in Indonesia. It delves into the nature of corporate criminal responsibility, the doctrines underlying it, actions triggering liability, attribution of responsibility to corporations, and trial procedures within the Indonesian judicial system. The paper also makes comparative references to Australia, providing a broader perspective on how different jurisdictions handle corporate environmental crimes.
Why it matters
The paper discusses the effectiveness of Indonesia's corporate criminal liability regime in deterring environmental violations. It notes that while the legal framework exists, enforcement remains challenging due to limited resources, corruption, and weak oversight. The authors argue that strengthening the identification doctrine and introducing clearer due diligence requirements could enhance accountability. The comparison with Australia suggests that Indonesia could benefit from adopting more robust enforcement practices and providing clearer guidance for corporations to comply with environmental laws. The discussion also highlights the importance of judicial capacity and the need for specialized environmental courts to handle complex corporate cases. Overall, the paper contributes to the understanding of how corporate criminal liability can be a tool for environmental protection, emphasizing the need for continuous legal reform and effective implementation.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ