Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2024
Criminal Liability Arising from Medical Malpractice on Patients: A Review from the Perspective of Positive Law And Islamic Law
This study examines criminal liability for medical malpractice by doctors in Indonesia, finding that existing health law is insufficient and that liability currently rests on Articles 359 and 360 of the Criminal Code. The authors call for explicit regulation of medical malpractice crimes in a new health law.
Rini Apriyani; Erna Susanti; Poppilea Erwinta; Kalen Sanata; Muh. Sakur Edwarni· KRTHA BHAYANGKARA· 2024· DOI 10.31599/krtha.v18i1.1615
The core problem
The paper opens by noting that suspicion in cases of medical malpractice is only slightly raised, even though actions by health professionals—doctors as medical personnel—have the potential to constitute malpractice that can be reported by the public. Such reports are often not resolved legally because the community has only limited knowledge of medical science and because there is no specific legal regulation governing malpractice in Indonesia. This gap means that occurrences of malpractice can cause legal problems. The study aims to determine criminal liability for medical malpractice acts committed by doctors against patients, in order to anticipate and deal with medical malpractice problems in criminal cases. The authors frame the issue within both positive law and Islamic law perspectives, signaling a comparative doctrinal approach.
Innovation
The research method used in this study is doctrinal. The author collects material from the literature, both hardcopy and softcopy, related to the title of the research, and uses an analysis of the research object. This library-based approach is consistent with doctrinal legal research, which focuses on the interpretation and systematization of legal norms rather than empirical data collection. The analysis proceeds by examining the relevant statutory provisions and legal principles under Indonesian positive law and Islamic law, and by assessing how criminal liability is currently attributed in cases of medical malpractice.
Introduction
The paper opens by noting that suspicion in cases of medical malpractice is only slightly raised, even though actions by health professionals—doctors as medical personnel—have the potential to constitute malpractice that can be reported by the public. Such reports are often not resolved legally because the community has only limited knowledge of medical science and because there is no specific legal regulation governing malpractice in Indonesia. This gap means that occurrences of malpractice can cause legal problems. The study aims to determine criminal liability for medical malpractice acts committed by doctors against patients, in order to anticipate and deal with medical malpractice problems in criminal cases. The authors frame the issue within both positive law and Islamic law perspectives, signaling a comparative doctrinal approach.
Why it matters
The authors argue that health law in Indonesia is considered insufficient and does not clearly regulate the crime of medical malpractice. The absence of explicit statutory language leaves uncertainty regarding the boundaries of criminal liability for doctors. Consequently, the study concludes that it is necessary to regulate the crime of medical malpractice by giving birth to a new health law—one that explicitly regulates criminal liability for medical malpractice acts by doctors against patients in Indonesia. The discussion also incorporates an Islamic law perspective, comparing how Islamic legal principles approach negligence and harm in medical treatment, although the abstract does not detail specific Islamic law provisions. The overall analysis underscores the need for legal reform to provide clearer guidance for both patients and health professionals.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…