Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholatโ€ฆ

Pertanian & Lingkungan editorial

Open AccessOA2026

Curiosity and Controversy: The Emerging Field of Regenerative Agriculture in Norway

This study explores how Norwegian farmers navigate knowledge controversies in regenerative agriculture, challenging the dominant agronomic paradigm through the 'microbial anomaly' and calling for interdisciplinary research.
Elina Engkvist; K. V. Lykkeยท Environment and Planning E Nature and Spaceยท 2026ยท DOI 10.1177/25148486261478093

The core problem

The article investigates the emerging field of regenerative agriculture in Norway, focusing on the knowledge controversies that arise as farmers adopt practices that deviate from conventional agronomy. Drawing on Thomas Kuhn's concept of paradigm shifts and Thomas Gieryn's cultural boundaries of science, the authors examine how farmers challenge agronomic foundations, combine scientific fields, and bridge social barriers. The study is based on interviews and participant observations conducted over four growing seasons, providing deep insights into the lived experiences of regenerative farmers. The central research question revolves around how farmers navigate the tensions between traditional agricultural science and emerging regenerative practices, and what this means for the future of agriculture.

Innovation

The research employs a qualitative approach, utilizing interviews and participant observation over four growing seasons. This longitudinal engagement allowed the researchers to build trust with farmers and observe the evolution of their practices and beliefs over time. The analysis is framed by Kuhn's paradigm shift theory and Gieryn's cultural boundaries of science, which help to conceptualize the challenges farmers face in legitimizing their knowledge. The study focuses on Norwegian farmers who are actively engaged in regenerative agriculture, exploring how they encounter and respond to what the authors term the 'microbial anomaly'.
Introduction
The article investigates the emerging field of regenerative agriculture in Norway, focusing on the knowledge controversies that arise as farmers adopt practices that deviate from conventional agronomy. Drawing on Thomas Kuhn's concept of paradigm shifts and Thomas Gieryn's cultural boundaries of science, the authors examine how farmers challenge agronomic foundations, combine scientific fields, and bridge social barriers. The study is based on interviews and participant observations conducted over four growing seasons, providing deep insights into the lived experiences of regenerative farmers. The central research question revolves around how farmers navigate the tensions between traditional agricultural science and emerging regenerative practices, and what this means for the future of agriculture.

Why it matters

The authors analyze these findings through the lens of paradigm shifts and cultural boundaries. They argue that the microbial anomaly represents a potential paradigm shift in agriculture, one that challenges the reductionist approach of modern agronomy by foregrounding microbially mediated plant nutrition and health. However, the structural support for such an agronomy remains marginal, and whether a large-scale shift occurs depends on scientific and agronomic credibility contests as well as on which visions of the future are invested in. The study highlights the political and societal implications, including farmer livelihoods and autonomy over food production. The authors suggest that farmer-led research combining science with local knowledge offers novel opportunities for agricultural transformation, but that the assimilation of the microbial anomaly into the status quo is not guaranteed. At stake is whether agriculture shifts from driving environmental degeneration to regeneration.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member contentโ€ฆ