Ilmu Sosial editorial
Open AccessOA2026
Cynical Theories: How Activist Scholarship Made Everything About Race, Gender, and Identity—and Why This Harms Everybody
Nils Borquist reviews Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay's Cynical Theories, which examines how post-Enlightenment scientific methods accelerated intellectual breakthroughs, and how activist scholarship has since reshaped academia around race, gender, and identity.
Nils Borquist· Verba Vitae· 2026· DOI 10.66100/vvj.v3i1.105
The core problem
The review by Nils Borquist introduces Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay's book *Cynical Theories*, which explores the infiltration of post-Enlightenment emphasis on the scientific method into universities and scholastic institutions. The authors argue that this emphasis proved valuable in accelerating intellectual breakthroughs across fields such as medicine, physics, anthropology, and philosophy. Consequently, a collection of methods known as liberal practices became significant for making discoveries. The subsequent decades were incredibly progressive in terms of new ideas and innovation, serving as the precursor to Pluckrose and Lindsay's text.
Innovation
The review does not explicitly detail the methodology of the book. However, based on the description, Pluckrose and Lindsay likely employ a historical and philosophical analysis of academic trends, tracing the shift from Enlightenment ideals to postmodern and activist scholarship. Their approach involves examining how liberal practices and scientific methods have been challenged or replaced by theories focusing on race, gender, and identity.
Introduction
The review by Nils Borquist introduces Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay's book *Cynical Theories*, which explores the infiltration of post-Enlightenment emphasis on the scientific method into universities and scholastic institutions. The authors argue that this emphasis proved valuable in accelerating intellectual breakthroughs across fields such as medicine, physics, anthropology, and philosophy. Consequently, a collection of methods known as liberal practices became significant for making discoveries. The subsequent decades were incredibly progressive in terms of new ideas and innovation, serving as the precursor to Pluckrose and Lindsay's text.
Why it matters
Borquist's review highlights the book's argument that the post-Enlightenment emphasis on the scientific method accelerated intellectual breakthroughs across various fields. The authors contend that the fruitful period of innovation serves as a precursor to their critique. They discuss how liberal practices were crucial for discoveries and how the shift towards activist scholarship may undermine these gains. The review suggests that Pluckrose and Lindsay's work is a critique of how academic institutions have been influenced by cynical theories that prioritize identity over empirical inquiry.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…