Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Ekonomi & Bisnis editorial

Open AccessOA2024

Defining artificial intelligence as a policy problem: A discourse network analysis from Germany

This study analyzes 6,421 statements from German political actors to reveal that AI is predominantly framed as a technology and innovation policy issue, with consumer protection, labor, and education receiving less attention.
Nicole Lemke; Philipp Trein; Frédéric Varone· European Policy Analysis· 2024· DOI 10.1002/epa2.1203

The core problem

Scholars agree that digital technologies such as artificial intelligence (AI) pose a political challenge. In this article, we study empirically how different actors in the German political system define AI as a policy problem. We use an original data set of 6421 statements by representatives of political parties, interest groups, scientific experts, and public officials in parliamentary debates, government consultations, and quality newspapers. The research question addresses how AI is framed as a policy problem by various stakeholders, which is crucial for understanding agenda-setting and policy design.

Innovation

The authors employ Discourse Network Analysis (DNA) combined with quantitative text analysis. The dataset comprises 6,421 statements from four actor groups: political parties, interest groups, scientific experts, and public officials. Statements were collected from three sources: parliamentary debates, government consultations, and quality newspapers. DNA allows for the mapping of actors and concepts, revealing shared beliefs and discourse coalitions. Quantitative text analysis, such as frequency and co-occurrence analysis, identifies dominant frames and their linkages.
Introduction
Scholars agree that digital technologies such as artificial intelligence (AI) pose a political challenge. In this article, we study empirically how different actors in the German political system define AI as a policy problem. We use an original data set of 6421 statements by representatives of political parties, interest groups, scientific experts, and public officials in parliamentary debates, government consultations, and quality newspapers. The research question addresses how AI is framed as a policy problem by various stakeholders, which is crucial for understanding agenda-setting and policy design.

Why it matters

The results imply that the capacity of the national government to reduce problem definition uncertainty and to steer the political agenda is difficult. Most actors focus on technological innovation rather than civil rights-related aspects, which may lead to policy blind spots. The dominance of innovation framing suggests that AI policy in Germany is primarily driven by economic competitiveness concerns, potentially at the expense of comprehensive regulatory frameworks addressing ethical and social challenges. This has implications for policy coherence and the inclusion of diverse stakeholder perspectives.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…