Ekonomi & Bisnis editorial
Open AccessOA2022
Do the Determinants of Foreign Direct Investment Have a Reverse and Symmetric Impact on Foreign Direct Divestment?
This study tests whether conventional drivers of bilateral foreign direct investment (FDI) have a reverse but symmetric impact on foreign direct divestment (FDD). Using data from 126 countries (2005โ2018), it finds that gravity variables affect FDD with the same sign as FDI, rejecting the symmetry hypothesis.
Alfred A. Haug; Anh T. N. Nguyen; P. D. Owenยท Empirical Economicsยท 2022ยท DOI 10.1007/s00181-022-02263-z
The core problem
Foreign direct divestment (FDD), or negative foreign direct investment, has received little attention in international macroeconomics. This paper addresses this gap by investigating whether the conventional determinants of bilateral foreign direct investment (FDI) have a reverse, but symmetric, impact on FDD. The authors argue that understanding FDD is crucial because divestment decisions may not simply mirror investment decisions. The study is the first country-level analysis to formally test the symmetry hypothesis: that coefficients on the determinants of the absolute value of divestment are equal but opposite in sign to those for investment. The motivation stems from the observation that if FDI and FDD are driven by the same factors but in opposite directions, then policies promoting FDI might simultaneously reduce FDD. However, if the effects are same-signed, then factors that attract FDI may also attract FDD, complicating policy design. The paper uses bilateral negative and positive FDI data between 126 countries or territories from 2005 to 2018 to examine this question.
Innovation
The authors employ a gravity model framework, which is standard in the FDI literature. The baseline specification relates bilateral FDI (positive) and FDD (negative) to conventional gravity variables: host and source country GDP, distance between countries, and source-country remoteness. The key innovation is to estimate separate equations for FDI and the absolute value of FDD, and then test whether the coefficients on the determinants of FDD are equal but opposite in sign to those for FDI. Formally, for each determinant , the symmetry hypothesis is
, where and are the coefficients in the FDI and FDD equations, respectively. The data cover bilateral negative and positive FDI flows between 126 countries or territories from 2005 to 2018. The authors use panel data techniques, likely including fixed effects to control for unobserved heterogeneity. They also address potential endogeneity issues, though the exact methods are not detailed in the abstract. The empirical strategy allows them to compare the signs and magnitudes of the estimated coefficients across the two types of flows.
Introduction
Foreign direct divestment (FDD), or negative foreign direct investment, has received little attention in international macroeconomics. This paper addresses this gap by investigating whether the conventional determinants of bilateral foreign direct investment (FDI) have a reverse, but symmetric, impact on FDD. The authors argue that understanding FDD is crucial because divestment decisions may not simply mirror investment decisions. The study is the first country-level analysis to formally test the symmetry hypothesis: that coefficients on the determinants of the absolute value of divestment are equal but opposite in sign to those for investment. The motivation stems from the observation that if FDI and FDD are driven by the same factors but in opposite directions, then policies promoting FDI might simultaneously reduce FDD. However, if the effects are same-signed, then factors that attract FDI may also attract FDD, complicating policy design. The paper uses bilateral negative and positive FDI data between 126 countries or territories from 2005 to 2018 to examine this question.
Why it matters
The rejection of the symmetry hypothesis has important implications for both theory and policy. Theoretically, it suggests that FDI and FDD are not simply two sides of the same coin; rather, they may be driven by similar underlying factors but through different mechanisms. For instance, a large host market may attract both new investments and divestments as firms enter and exit, reflecting dynamic market conditions. The authors' finding challenges the conventional wisdom that divestment is merely the reverse of investment. From a policy perspective, the results imply that measures to promote FDI may not automatically deter FDD. Policymakers should therefore consider separate strategies for retaining investment and managing divestment. The study also highlights the need for more research on the determinants of FDD, as it is a relatively understudied area. The use of bilateral data across 126 countries over 14 years provides robust evidence, but the authors acknowledge limitations such as potential measurement issues and the need for firm-level analysis to uncover microeconomic mechanisms. Overall, the paper contributes to a deeper understanding of international capital flows by showing that FDD deserves independent attention.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ