Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2023
Due Process of Law: Pre-trial and Preliminary Examination Judge on Indonesian Criminal Procedure Law
This study finds that Indonesia's current pretrial mechanism does not reflect due process of law, necessitating reform. The proposed Preliminary Examination Judge in the RKUHAP offers greater authority to protect suspect rights, potentially achieving the criminal procedure law's goal of due process of law (behoorlijk procesrecht).
Fitriah Faisal· Scholars International Journal of Law Crime and Justice· 2023· DOI 10.36348/sijlcj.2023.v06i03.003
The core problem
The research addresses the question of whether the pretrial institution (praperadilan) in Indonesian criminal procedure law has realized the due process of law as aspired by the criminal procedural law (KUHAP). It further examines whether the proposed reform institution in the RKUHAP—the Preliminary Examination Judge (Hakim Pemeriksaan Pendahuluan)—can better reflect due process of law. The study is motivated by the need to align criminal procedure with the fundamental principle of due process, or behoorlijk procesrecht, which seeks material truth and protects the human rights of suspects and defendants.
Innovation
The research employs a normative legal research method. Data sources consist of secondary data, including primary, secondary, and tertiary legal materials. Data collection is conducted through library techniques, and the data is analyzed using qualitative methods, described systematically or prescriptively. This approach allows the researcher to evaluate the existing legal framework and the proposed reforms against the standard of due process of law.
Introduction
The research addresses the question of whether the pretrial institution (praperadilan) in Indonesian criminal procedure law has realized the due process of law as aspired by the criminal procedural law (KUHAP). It further examines whether the proposed reform institution in the RKUHAP—the Preliminary Examination Judge (Hakim Pemeriksaan Pendahuluan)—can better reflect due process of law. The study is motivated by the need to align criminal procedure with the fundamental principle of due process, or behoorlijk procesrecht, which seeks material truth and protects the human rights of suspects and defendants.
Why it matters
The analysis centers on the gap between the current pretrial institution and the ideal of due process of law. The pretrial mechanism, as it stands, fails to adequately safeguard suspect rights, prompting the need for reform. The Preliminary Examination Judge, as proposed in the RKUHAP, is designed to address these shortcomings by granting broader authority to oversee the pre-trial process. This reform is grounded in the principle of behoorlijk procesrecht, which emphasizes fair procedure and the protection of human rights. The study concludes that the establishment of the Preliminary Examination Judge is a necessary step toward achieving the criminal procedure law's objectives of material truth and human rights protection.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…