Ekonomi & Bisnis editorial
Open AccessOA2022
Dynamic Competition and Arbitrage in Electricity Markets: The Role of Financial Players
Financial traders in electricity markets can reduce generators' market power and increase consumer surplus, but the effect depends on the equilibrium type. A new test rejects static Nash equilibrium in favor of dynamic competition.
Ignacia Mercadalยท American Economic Journal: Microeconomicsยท 2022ยท DOI 10.1257/mic.20190276
The core problem
The paper investigates the impact of financial players who trade alongside physical buyers and sellers in electricity markets. The author uses detailed firm-level data to examine how both physical and financial firms respond to regulation that exogenously increased financial trading. The central question is whether speculators enhance competition or facilitate market power. The study finds that the effect hinges on the type of equilibrium: in a static Nash equilibrium, financial traders might have different implications than in a dynamic setting. The author develops a test to distinguish between static and dynamic competition, rejecting the null of static Nash equilibrium. To implement this test, a novel method using machine-learning tools is introduced to define markets. The results show that increased financial trading reduced generators' market power and increased consumer surplus. The paper contributes to the literature on market design and the role of financial participants in commodity markets.
Innovation
The empirical strategy exploits a regulation that exogenously increased financial trading in electricity markets. Using firm-level data, the author observes the behavior of physical and financial firms. A key methodological innovation is the use of machine-learning tools to define markets, which is essential for implementing the test of static versus dynamic equilibrium. The test is based on the null hypothesis of static Nash equilibrium. The author likely estimates a model of supply and demand, incorporating financial traders' positions. The machine-learning approach helps identify relevant market boundaries, which are crucial in electricity markets due to transmission constraints. The test compares observed behavior with the predictions of static Nash equilibrium. If the null is rejected, it suggests that firms are engaged in dynamic competition, such as tacit collusion or other repeated game strategies. The methodology combines structural econometrics with machine learning for market definition.
Introduction
The paper investigates the impact of financial players who trade alongside physical buyers and sellers in electricity markets. The author uses detailed firm-level data to examine how both physical and financial firms respond to regulation that exogenously increased financial trading. The central question is whether speculators enhance competition or facilitate market power. The study finds that the effect hinges on the type of equilibrium: in a static Nash equilibrium, financial traders might have different implications than in a dynamic setting. The author develops a test to distinguish between static and dynamic competition, rejecting the null of static Nash equilibrium. To implement this test, a novel method using machine-learning tools is introduced to define markets. The results show that increased financial trading reduced generators' market power and increased consumer surplus. The paper contributes to the literature on market design and the role of financial participants in commodity markets.
Why it matters
The paper's analysis highlights the importance of considering dynamic competition when evaluating the effects of financial trading. The rejection of static Nash equilibrium implies that policies based on static models may be misleading. The use of machine learning for market definition is a methodological contribution that can be applied to other markets with complex boundaries. The finding that financial trading reduces market power challenges the view that speculators are harmful. Instead, financial players can enhance liquidity and competition. The author discusses potential mechanisms: financial traders may arbitrage price differences, leading to more efficient pricing. However, the effect depends on the market structure and the type of equilibrium. The paper concludes with policy implications: regulators should consider the dynamic nature of competition and the role of financial participants. The JEL codes (C45, D83, G13, L13, L94, L98, Q41) indicate the paper's relevance to econometrics, information, financial markets, industrial organization, and energy economics.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ