Pendidikan editorial
Open AccessOA2025
EducationQ: Evaluating LLMs' Teaching Capabilities Through Multi-Agent Dialogue Framework
EducationQ introduces a multi-agent dialogue framework to evaluate LLM teaching capabilities, finding that pedagogical effectiveness is not correlated with model scale or general reasoning. The study highlights the need for specialized optimization for educational AI.
Yao Shi; Rong Liang; Yong-Jun Xuยท Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguisticsยท 2025ยท DOI 10.18653/v1/2025.acl-long.1576
The core problem
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used as educational tools, but evaluating their teaching capabilities is challenging due to the resource-intensive, context-dependent, and methodologically complex nature of teacher-student interactions. Current evaluations often prioritize knowledge recall over interactive pedagogy, leaving a gap in assessing how well LLMs can actually teach. To address this, the authors introduce EducationQ, a multi-agent dialogue framework that efficiently assesses teaching capabilities through simulated dynamic educational scenarios. The framework features specialized agents for teaching, learning, and evaluation, enabling scalable and systematic assessment of LLM teaching effectiveness.
Innovation
EducationQ employs a multi-agent dialogue framework where three types of agents interact: a teaching agent (the LLM being evaluated), a learning agent (simulated student), and an evaluation agent (assessing teaching quality). The framework simulates dynamic educational scenarios, allowing for efficient and context-dependent evaluation. The study tested 14 LLMs from major AI organizations (OpenAI, Meta, Google, Anthropic, and others) on 1,498 questions spanning 13 disciplines and 10 difficulty levels. The evaluation combines quantitative metrics with qualitative analysis and expert case studies to identify pedagogical strengths. Human expert evaluations were used to validate the automated qualitative analysis, showing 78% agreement on effective teaching behaviors.
Introduction
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used as educational tools, but evaluating their teaching capabilities is challenging due to the resource-intensive, context-dependent, and methodologically complex nature of teacher-student interactions. Current evaluations often prioritize knowledge recall over interactive pedagogy, leaving a gap in assessing how well LLMs can actually teach. To address this, the authors introduce EducationQ, a multi-agent dialogue framework that efficiently assesses teaching capabilities through simulated dynamic educational scenarios. The framework features specialized agents for teaching, learning, and evaluation, enabling scalable and systematic assessment of LLM teaching effectiveness.
Why it matters
The study demonstrates that LLMs-as-teachers require specialized optimization beyond simple scaling. The lack of correlation between model size and teaching effectiveness suggests that next-generation educational AI should prioritize targeted enhancement of specific pedagogical effectiveness. The EducationQ framework provides a scalable and efficient method for evaluating teaching capabilities, which can guide the development of more effective educational AI. The findings underscore the importance of interactive pedagogy in educational AI and the need for evaluation methods that go beyond knowledge recall.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ