Pendidikan editorial
Open AccessOA2025
Effect of Interactive Learning Environments on Learning Outcomes in Science Education: A Network Meta-Analysis
This network meta-analysis of 53 primary studies finds that mixed reality yields the largest effect size versus conventional teaching, while augmented reality is ranked most effective overall for both cognitive and affective outcomes. VR and digital games show selective benefits, with high heterogeneity and publication bias noted as limitations.
Adem Koç; Sedat Kanadlı· Journal of Science Education and Technology· 2025· DOI 10.1007/s10956-025-10202-7
The core problem
Interactive learning environments (ILEs)—including augmented reality (AR), virtual reality (VR), mixed reality (MIX), and interactive digital games (GAME)—are increasingly used in science education. This study employs network meta-analysis to compare their effects on learning outcomes against conventional teaching (CON) and against each other. The objective is to determine which ILE formats are most effective for cognitive and affective outcomes, and to rank them accordingly.
Innovation
A systematic literature search identified 53 primary studies meeting predefined inclusion/exclusion criteria. Network meta-analysis was used to synthesize direct and indirect comparisons among the four ILE formats and conventional teaching. Effect sizes were calculated for cognitive and affective outcomes. Heterogeneity and publication bias were assessed. The analysis also produced rankings of the ILE formats for each outcome type.
Introduction
Interactive learning environments (ILEs)—including augmented reality (AR), virtual reality (VR), mixed reality (MIX), and interactive digital games (GAME)—are increasingly used in science education. This study employs network meta-analysis to compare their effects on learning outcomes against conventional teaching (CON) and against each other. The objective is to determine which ILE formats are most effective for cognitive and affective outcomes, and to rank them accordingly.
Why it matters
The findings highlight the potential of ILEs, particularly AR, for enhancing learning outcomes in science education. MIX showed the largest effect size versus conventional teaching, but the lack of direct comparisons for MIX limits confidence in this result. High heterogeneity across studies and publication bias in some binary comparisons are notable limitations. The ranking of AR as most effective for both outcome types suggests that AR may offer a balanced benefit across cognitive and affective domains. However, the indirect nature of some comparisons and the limited number of primary studies for certain formats (especially MIX) warrant caution. More primary studies with direct comparisons are needed to address these limitations and increase the generalizability of the findings.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…