Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholatโ€ฆ

Hukum editorial

Open AccessOA2025

Electronic Trials in Indonesian Criminal Courts: Issues and the Urgency for Legal Reform

This study examines the legal void in Indonesia's Criminal Procedure Code regarding electronic criminal trials and proposes a legislative framework modeled on the U.S. CARES Act, alongside technological readiness guarantees.
Widyo Brayoto Ardi; Eugenio Gusmaoยท Indonesian Journal of Crime and Criminal Justiceยท 2025ยท DOI 10.62264/ijccj.v2i1.224

The core problem

The study addresses the urgent need for legal reform in Indonesia's criminal justice system to accommodate electronic trials. Despite the digital transformation in various sectors, the Indonesian Criminal Procedure Code (Law No. 8 of 1981 and Law No. 20 of 2025 on the New Criminal Code) lacks explicit provisions for conducting criminal trials electronically. This legal vacuum creates uncertainty and hinders law enforcement, especially in situations requiring remote proceedings. The authors aim to provide prescriptions for electronic justice by designing a framework for its realization in Indonesia, drawing on comparative law insights from the United States.

Innovation

This research employs normative legal research with a comparative law approach. The analysis focuses on the practice and regulation of electronic trials in the United States, particularly the CARES Act, as a benchmark. The study examines primary legal materials, including Indonesian statutes and U.S. legislation, to identify gaps and propose reforms. The normative method is used to assess the consistency and completeness of existing laws and to formulate prescriptive recommendations.
Introduction
The study addresses the urgent need for legal reform in Indonesia's criminal justice system to accommodate electronic trials. Despite the digital transformation in various sectors, the Indonesian Criminal Procedure Code (Law No. 8 of 1981 and Law No. 20 of 2025 on the New Criminal Code) lacks explicit provisions for conducting criminal trials electronically. This legal vacuum creates uncertainty and hinders law enforcement, especially in situations requiring remote proceedings. The authors aim to provide prescriptions for electronic justice by designing a framework for its realization in Indonesia, drawing on comparative law insights from the United States.

Why it matters

The study argues that Indonesia must enact a dedicated law on electronic justice and revise the Criminal Procedure Code to provide a clear legal basis for electronic trials. The U.S. CARES Act serves as a model, offering detailed provisions on technical standards, participant rights, and procedural safeguards. The authors propose a framework that includes:

- **Legislative Reform**: Enactment of a law governing electronic justice and amendment of the Criminal Procedure Code to incorporate electronic trial mechanisms.
- **Standardization**: Development of technical standards and protocols for electronic trials, ensuring fairness and due process.
- **Infrastructure and Resource Readiness**: Investment in technology and training for court personnel, judges, prosecutors, and defense counsel to ensure effective participation.

The analysis emphasizes that without such reforms, the digital transformation of criminal justice will remain incomplete and potentially undermine the right to a fair trial. The study concludes with a call for urgent action to align Indonesia's legal framework with technological advancements and international best practices.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member contentโ€ฆ