Ekonomi & Bisnis editorial
Open AccessOA2023
Environmental Regulation and Labor Demand: What Does the Evidence Tell Us?
This review synthesizes neoclassical frameworks and empirical evidence on the labor demand effects of environmental regulation, covering partial and general equilibrium approaches and labor supply impacts. It identifies remaining research gaps in understanding both short- and long-term employment consequences.
Wayne D. Gray; Ronald J. Shadbegian; A. Wolvertonยท Annual Review of Resource Economicsยท 2023ยท DOI 10.1146/annurev-resource-101422-115834
The core problem
The potential effect of environmental regulation on employment is of broad interest to key stakeholders. Concerns encompass both short- and longer-term effects on workers within the regulated sector, affected communities that already suffer from a lack of employment opportunities, and net employment in the overall economy. This review by Gray, Shadbegian, and Wolverton, published in the *Annual Review of Resource Economics* (Volume 15, expected October 2023), examines what the evidence tells us about these relationships. The authors begin by presenting a neoclassical microeconomic framework to demonstrate how environmental regulations might affect labor demand, then summarize the main empirical findings from the literature, including sector-specific partial equilibrium estimates and general equilibrium approaches. They also briefly describe the literature on how environmental regulations affect labor supply, and finally discuss remaining research gaps.
Innovation
The review adopts a systematic approach to synthesizing the literature. It first develops a neoclassical microeconomic framework that illustrates the theoretical channels through which environmental regulations can influence labor demand. This framework serves as a lens for organizing and interpreting the empirical evidence. The authors then survey empirical studies, categorizing them into two main methodological strands: sector-specific partial equilibrium estimates and general equilibrium approaches. Partial equilibrium studies typically focus on regulated industries and estimate employment effects using plant-level or industry-level data, often exploiting variation in regulatory stringency. General equilibrium approaches attempt to capture economy-wide effects, accounting for spillovers across sectors and regions. The review also includes a brief discussion of the literature on labor supply effects, which examines how regulations might affect workers' decisions to supply labor, for example through changes in health, amenities, or reservation wages. The authors conclude by identifying gaps in the existing research.
Introduction
The potential effect of environmental regulation on employment is of broad interest to key stakeholders. Concerns encompass both short- and longer-term effects on workers within the regulated sector, affected communities that already suffer from a lack of employment opportunities, and net employment in the overall economy. This review by Gray, Shadbegian, and Wolverton, published in the *Annual Review of Resource Economics* (Volume 15, expected October 2023), examines what the evidence tells us about these relationships. The authors begin by presenting a neoclassical microeconomic framework to demonstrate how environmental regulations might affect labor demand, then summarize the main empirical findings from the literature, including sector-specific partial equilibrium estimates and general equilibrium approaches. They also briefly describe the literature on how environmental regulations affect labor supply, and finally discuss remaining research gaps.
Why it matters
The authors discuss the implications of the findings and highlight remaining research gaps. They emphasize that understanding the employment effects of environmental regulation requires careful consideration of both short- and long-term dynamics, as well as the distinction between partial and general equilibrium perspectives. Key gaps include the need for more research on the long-term effects, the distributional consequences for vulnerable communities, and the interaction between labor demand and labor supply responses. The review also points to methodological challenges, such as identifying causal effects and accounting for general equilibrium adjustments. The authors suggest that future work should integrate more comprehensive data and modeling approaches to better inform policy design. Overall, the review provides a balanced assessment of what is known and what remains uncertain about the labor market consequences of environmental regulation.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ