Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Ilmu Sosial editorial

Open AccessOA2026

Ethnography and Ethnographic Sensibility in Political Science

Fu, Nielsen, and Schatz argue that ethnographic sensibility—immersive, reflexive, and ethically attuned—remains indispensable in political science, even as digital methods and AI chatbots tempt researchers toward purely virtual fieldwork. They outline how ethnography-plus research and digital methods can be strengthened by ontological and epistemological reflection.
Diana Fu; Richard A. Nielsen; Edward Schatz· Annual review of political science (Palo Alto, Calif. Print)· 2026· DOI 10.1146/annurev-polisci-041224-084600

The core problem

In an era when artificial intelligence and chatbots make it enticing to interface with an entirely digital field site, immersive ethnographic practices and an ethnographic sensibility remain indispensable. The authors, Diana Fu, Richard A. Nielsen, and Edward Schatz, open by acknowledging the allure of digital tools but immediately assert that ethnography's core value persists. They define an ethnographic sensibility as a way of being and knowing that increases the fidelity of our theories to the real world, improves researchers' sensitivity to the ethical, emotional, and moral stakes of research, and sparks creativity. This introduction sets up the central tension: as more political scientists adopt an ethnographic sensibility, they are increasingly engaging in ethnography-plus research, which may include other qualitative or quantitative methods. The authors aim to assess the promise of these approaches, particularly in light of new digital research methods and the challenges of difficult-to-access settings.

Innovation

The article is a conceptual and methodological review rather than an empirical study. The authors synthesize existing literature and draw on their own expertise to examine the state of ethnographic research in political science. They consider new directions in digital research methods, especially for difficult-to-access settings in authoritarian regimes that involve navigating the thorny ethics of state surveillance. The methodology of the review involves an ontological and epistemological examination of what ethnography can and cannot deliver, particularly when combined with digital tools. The authors argue that digital research with an ethnographic sensibility could benefit from such examination. They also outline practical recommendations for the emerging generation of researchers looking to embrace an ethnographic sensibility: practice participant observation, embrace reflexivity, and attune to the body and sensations. This methodological discussion is framed as a guide for future research.
Introduction
In an era when artificial intelligence and chatbots make it enticing to interface with an entirely digital field site, immersive ethnographic practices and an ethnographic sensibility remain indispensable. The authors, Diana Fu, Richard A. Nielsen, and Edward Schatz, open by acknowledging the allure of digital tools but immediately assert that ethnography's core value persists. They define an ethnographic sensibility as a way of being and knowing that increases the fidelity of our theories to the real world, improves researchers' sensitivity to the ethical, emotional, and moral stakes of research, and sparks creativity. This introduction sets up the central tension: as more political scientists adopt an ethnographic sensibility, they are increasingly engaging in ethnography-plus research, which may include other qualitative or quantitative methods. The authors aim to assess the promise of these approaches, particularly in light of new digital research methods and the challenges of difficult-to-access settings.

Why it matters

The analysis section delves into the implications of these findings. The authors discuss the tension between digital convenience and the depth of immersive ethnography. They caution that while AI and chatbots may simulate interaction, they cannot replace the embodied, reflexive, and ethically attuned practices of traditional ethnography. The discussion emphasizes that an ethnographic sensibility is not just a set of techniques but a way of being that shapes how researchers approach their work. The authors explore the concept of ethnography-plus research, considering its potential and pitfalls. They argue that combining ethnography with other methods can enrich understanding but requires careful integration to avoid superficiality. The thorny ethics of state surveillance in authoritarian regimes are examined in detail, highlighting the risks to researchers and participants. The authors propose that an ontological and epistemological examination of ethnography's capabilities and limits is essential for digital research. Finally, they offer guidance for the emerging generation: practice participant observation, embrace reflexivity, and attune to the body and sensations. These practices, they argue, are essential for maintaining the integrity and impact of ethnographic research in political science.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…