Ilmu Sosial editorial
Open AccessOA2026
Explanation in Sociology and Coleman’s Diagram
Werner Raub argues that Coleman’s diagram visualizes rigorous sociology aligned with methodological individualism, where nodes and arrows represent key kinds of assumptions and implications. The diagram must be distinguished from theory and explanation as such.
Werner Raub· KZfSS Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie· 2026· DOI 10.1007/s11577-026-01047-y
The core problem
Coleman’s diagram is a well-known visualization in sociology, often used to depict the micro–macro links in explanations of social phenomena. In this contribution, Werner Raub argues for a specific interpretation: the nodes and arrows of the diagram should be conceived as representing key kinds of assumptions and implications of theory and explanation in sociology. This perspective aligns with methodological individualism and the pursuit of rigorous sociology. The paper discusses examples that highlight this perspective and explores various consequences of adopting it. A recurrent theme is the need to distinguish the diagram from theory and explanation as such.
Innovation
The contribution is a theoretical and methodological analysis. It does not report empirical data collection or statistical analysis. Instead, it examines the conceptual foundations of Coleman’s diagram, interpreting its components—nodes and arrows—as standing for specific types of assumptions and implications. The method involves illustrative examples that demonstrate how the diagram can be used to represent theoretical claims and explanatory strategies within the methodological individualist tradition. The analysis also considers the consequences of this interpretation for sociological practice, particularly regarding the relationship between the diagram and the theories or explanations it is meant to represent.
Introduction
Coleman’s diagram is a well-known visualization in sociology, often used to depict the micro–macro links in explanations of social phenomena. In this contribution, Werner Raub argues for a specific interpretation: the nodes and arrows of the diagram should be conceived as representing key kinds of assumptions and implications of theory and explanation in sociology. This perspective aligns with methodological individualism and the pursuit of rigorous sociology. The paper discusses examples that highlight this perspective and explores various consequences of adopting it. A recurrent theme is the need to distinguish the diagram from theory and explanation as such.
Why it matters
The central argument is that Coleman’s diagram should be distinguished from theory and explanation as such. While the diagram can represent the structure of an explanation—linking individual-level assumptions to macro-level outcomes—it does not constitute the explanation itself. This distinction is crucial for avoiding reification of the diagram and for maintaining clarity about the roles of assumptions, mechanisms, and implications in sociological theorizing. The methodological individualist perspective emphasizes that social phenomena are to be explained in terms of individual actions and their unintended consequences. Coleman’s diagram, when interpreted as representing assumptions and implications, serves as a valuable heuristic and communicative device. However, it must be supplemented by substantive theories and empirical evidence. The paper concludes by discussing the broader implications for rigorous sociology, including the need for explicit assumptions and the careful derivation of implications.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…