Pertanian & Lingkungan editorial
Failure to Scale in Digital Agronomy: An Analysis of Site-Specific Nutrient Management Decision-Support Tools in Developing Countries
The core problem
Innovation
Why it matters
The authors argue that the failure to scale SSNM-DSTs is largely due to a mismatch between the design of the tools and the realities of the users. While the tools effectively address in-field heterogeneity (e.g., soil variability), they often ignore the socioeconomic heterogeneity of users, such as differences in wealth, education, and access to resources. This oversight leads to tools that are not appropriate for the diverse contexts in which they are deployed.
The paper suggests that future efforts should move beyond a narrow focus on the biophysical aspects of nutrient management and incorporate institutional, economic, and governance dimensions. This includes:
- **Institutional support**: Strengthening extension systems and creating enabling policies.
- **Economic incentives**: Ensuring access to affordable inputs and markets.
- **Governance**: Involving stakeholders in the design and implementation of tools.
A conceptual framework for scaling is proposed, which integrates these dimensions. The authors emphasize that scaling is not merely a matter of disseminating technology but requires a systemic approach that addresses the broader context.
The analysis concludes that achieving scale requires a paradigm shift in how SSNM-DSTs are developed and deployed, with greater attention to the socioeconomic and institutional context.
Who should read this
Opening member contentโฆ