Ilmu Sosial editorial
Open AccessOA2022
From Anti-Government to Anti-Science: Why Conservatives Have Turned Against Science
Empirical data reveal a crisis of conservative trust in science, not a general public trust crisis. The authors argue that conservative hostility toward science is collateral damage from a carefully orchestrated conservative distrust of government, cultivated by business leaders for nearly a century.
N. Oreskes; E. Conway· Daedalus· 2022· DOI 10.1162/daed_a_01946
The core problem
The essay opens by challenging the common narrative of a widespread crisis of public trust in science. The authors assert that empirical data do not support the conclusion of a general crisis; instead, they support the conclusion of a crisis of conservative trust in science. Polls show that American attitudes toward science are highly polarized along political lines. This polarization is not a recent phenomenon but has deep roots in conservative ideology and political strategy. The authors aim to explain why conservatives have turned against science, tracing the origins to conservative hostility toward government regulation of the marketplace, which has morphed into hostility toward government itself. The introduction sets the stage for a historical and political analysis of how science, particularly environmental and public health science, became a target of anti-regulatory attitudes.
Innovation
The authors employ a historical and political analysis, drawing on empirical data from polls and surveys to demonstrate the polarization of attitudes toward science along political lines. They trace the evolution of conservative rhetoric and policy from the early 20th century through the Reagan administration to the present. The methodology involves examining the strategies of conservative business leaders and think tanks in cultivating distrust of government, and how this distrust spilled over onto science. The analysis is qualitative, synthesizing historical accounts, political speeches, and polling data to build a causal narrative. The authors also review literature on public trust in science and conservative political ideology to support their argument.
Introduction
The essay opens by challenging the common narrative of a widespread crisis of public trust in science. The authors assert that empirical data do not support the conclusion of a general crisis; instead, they support the conclusion of a crisis of conservative trust in science. Polls show that American attitudes toward science are highly polarized along political lines. This polarization is not a recent phenomenon but has deep roots in conservative ideology and political strategy. The authors aim to explain why conservatives have turned against science, tracing the origins to conservative hostility toward government regulation of the marketplace, which has morphed into hostility toward government itself. The introduction sets the stage for a historical and political analysis of how science, particularly environmental and public health science, became a target of anti-regulatory attitudes.
Why it matters
The authors argue that contemporary distrust of science is mostly collateral damage, a spillover from carefully orchestrated conservative distrust of government. They explain that the conservative movement's anti-regulatory stance, driven by business interests, led to a broader anti-government ideology. When scientific evidence pointed to the need for regulation—such as in the case of acid rain, ozone depletion, and climate change—conservatives attacked the science itself as a means to undermine regulatory efforts. This strategy has had unintended consequences: it has eroded public trust in science more broadly, even among issues not directly tied to regulation. The authors discuss the implications of this spillover for democratic governance and the role of expertise in policymaking. They conclude that rebuilding trust in science will require addressing the underlying political polarization and the deliberate cultivation of distrust by vested interests.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…