Ekonomi & Bisnis editorial
Open AccessOA2024
Governing the Economy Under Populist Rule: The Cases of Hungary and Poland
This digest examines the economic consequences of populist rule in Hungary and Poland, focusing on macroeconomic management, welfare policies, and market regulation. It finds that while both countries avoided classic irresponsible macroeconomic policies, they engaged in significant redistribution and tilted markets toward political allies, with Hungary favoring selective social policies and private property, and Poland adopting more inclusive welfare and increased state ownership.
István Benczes; Joanna Orzechowska-Wacławska· Problems of Post-Communism· 2024· DOI 10.1080/10758216.2023.2301085
The core problem
Populism is principally a political phenomenon, yet its economic implications can be substantial. This study operationalizes the ideational definition of populism to analyze the economic consequences of populist governance in Hungary and Poland. The authors focus on three major domains: macroeconomic management, welfare policies, and market regulation. The central question is how populist governments in these countries have shaped economic outcomes, and whether their policies align with the classical notion of "economic populism"—characterized by irresponsible macroeconomic policies such as accumulating public debt or external debt. The article demonstrates that while Hungary and Poland refrained from such irresponsible policies (at least until the COVID-19 pandemic), they embarked on widescale income and wealth redistribution. However, the targets and strategies of redistribution differed significantly between the two countries.
Innovation
The authors employ a qualitative comparative case study approach, operationalizing the ideational definition of populism. This definition views populism as a thin-centered ideology that considers society to be ultimately separated into two homogeneous and antagonistic groups: "the pure people" versus "the corrupt elite," and argues that politics should be an expression of the volonté générale (general will) of the people. By applying this framework, the study systematically examines policy outputs in three domains: macroeconomic management, welfare policies, and market regulation. Data are drawn from a range of sources, including government documents, policy reports, and economic indicators from Hungary and Poland during the period of populist rule (from 2010 in Hungary and 2015 in Poland). The analysis focuses on identifying how populist ideas translate into specific economic policies and outcomes.
Introduction
Populism is principally a political phenomenon, yet its economic implications can be substantial. This study operationalizes the ideational definition of populism to analyze the economic consequences of populist governance in Hungary and Poland. The authors focus on three major domains: macroeconomic management, welfare policies, and market regulation. The central question is how populist governments in these countries have shaped economic outcomes, and whether their policies align with the classical notion of "economic populism"—characterized by irresponsible macroeconomic policies such as accumulating public debt or external debt. The article demonstrates that while Hungary and Poland refrained from such irresponsible policies (at least until the COVID-19 pandemic), they embarked on widescale income and wealth redistribution. However, the targets and strategies of redistribution differed significantly between the two countries.
Why it matters
The findings suggest that populist governance does not necessarily lead to macroeconomic irresponsibility, but it does lead to a politicization of economic policy. The Hungarian approach can be characterized as a "selective populism" that reinforces social inequalities while maintaining a facade of private property rights. The Polish approach, on the other hand, represents a "inclusive populism" that combines redistribution to the poor with a statist economic model. These differences can be attributed to the distinct ideological roots of the governing parties: Fidesz in Hungary espouses a national-conservative ideology with a strong emphasis on the middle class, while Law and Justice (PiS) in Poland combines social conservatism with economic interventionism. The study also highlights the role of external actors, such as the European Union, in constraining extreme macroeconomic populism. The COVID-19 pandemic has further accelerated state intervention in both economies, potentially deepening these trends. The article concludes that populist economic governance poses a threat to liberal democracy by undermining checks and balances and creating new forms of clientelism, even when macroeconomic stability is maintained.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…