Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Hukum editorial

Open AccessOA2024

Hawala in Criminal Court: The Role of Law and Commercial Culture in Informal Financial Exchange

This paper argues that the Sharia-based normative and cultural framework of ḥawāla, embedded in Muslim social networks, provides a tool for courts to differentiate legitimate from illegitimate informal value transfers, challenging the predominant New Institutional Economics perspective that overlooks these normative characteristics.
Jonathan G. Ercanbrack· Crime, law and social change· 2024· DOI 10.1007/s10611-024-10162-w

The core problem

The paper opens by asserting that a historically informed understanding of ḥawāla and other informal value transfer systems (IVTS) must consider the normative and cultural elements that structure and facilitate transactions in globalized financial markets. The author positions the argument against the predominant scholarly approach—the New Institutional Economics (NIE) explanation—which views economic institutions through the lens of profit-making and self-interest-centered institutional development. The NIE perspective, the paper contends, neglects the common frame of reference built on community, shared belief, and normative rules and expectations that underpin ḥawāla. This neglect is particularly problematic in a criminal law context, where the profit-oriented perspective of law overlooks the normative characteristics that sometimes appear in the transactional characteristics of these exchanges. The paper's central thesis is that the Sharia-based normative and cultural framework of ḥawāla is created in the social relations of Muslim networks and that, in a criminal law context, this normativity can be used as a tool to discern between legitimate and illegitimate transactions.

Innovation

The paper employs a conceptual and comparative analysis, drawing on historical and socio-legal scholarship to critique the NIE framework and propose an alternative understanding of ḥawāla. It examines the normative and cultural dimensions of ḥawāla as embedded in Muslim networks, contrasting these with the profit-oriented assumptions of NIE. The methodology is qualitative, focusing on the interpretation of legal and cultural norms rather than empirical data collection. The author synthesizes insights from Islamic law, economic sociology, and criminal law to develop a framework for courts to evaluate evidence of ḥawāla transactions. The analysis is situated within the context of globalized financial markets and the challenges they pose for legal systems unfamiliar with non-Western commercial practices.
Introduction
The paper opens by asserting that a historically informed understanding of ḥawāla and other informal value transfer systems (IVTS) must consider the normative and cultural elements that structure and facilitate transactions in globalized financial markets. The author positions the argument against the predominant scholarly approach—the New Institutional Economics (NIE) explanation—which views economic institutions through the lens of profit-making and self-interest-centered institutional development. The NIE perspective, the paper contends, neglects the common frame of reference built on community, shared belief, and normative rules and expectations that underpin ḥawāla. This neglect is particularly problematic in a criminal law context, where the profit-oriented perspective of law overlooks the normative characteristics that sometimes appear in the transactional characteristics of these exchanges. The paper's central thesis is that the Sharia-based normative and cultural framework of ḥawāla is created in the social relations of Muslim networks and that, in a criminal law context, this normativity can be used as a tool to discern between legitimate and illegitimate transactions.

Why it matters

The discussion elaborates on the implications of these findings for criminal law. The author argues that the NIE's profit-oriented lens is insufficient for understanding ḥawāla because it ignores the normative and cultural framework that shapes legitimate transactions. In a criminal law context, this oversight can lead to mischaracterization of legitimate transfers as criminal. The paper proposes that courts should consider evidence of network density, shared belief, and normative expectations as indicators of legitimacy. Conversely, the presence of violence, profit-orientation, and diverse participants may indicate criminal activity. The author acknowledges that the NIE perspective has dominated scholarly work but contends that it fails to capture the full complexity of ḥawāla. The paper concludes by emphasizing the need for legal systems to incorporate cultural and historical context into their assessment of informal value transfer systems, particularly in multicultural societies.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…