Ilmu Sosial editorial
Open AccessOA2024
Health Emergencies, Science Contrarianism and Populism: A Scoping Review
A scoping review of 283 studies reveals that populism's relationship with health emergencies and science contrarianism is context-dependent and non-linear, with research overly focused on Brazil and the US. The author proposes a policy typology to better analyze political responses to health crises.
M. Schenkelยท Social Science & Medicine (1967)ยท 2024ยท DOI 10.1016/j.socscimed.2024.116691
The core problem
Populism has been frequently cited by media and scholars as a key factor in the mishandling of the COVID-19 crisis. However, the relationship between public health and populism predates the pandemic and extends beyond it. This paper provides a comprehensive overview of existing evidence and theoretical conceptualizations on the intersection of populism, health emergencies, and contrarian scientific positions, drawing from multiple disciplines. The author conducts a scoping review of 283 original studies, analyzing their analytical frameworks, geographic focuses, and methodological approaches. The review aims to synthesize the fragmented literature and propose a more nuanced understanding of how populism interacts with health crises and science.
Innovation
The author conducted a scoping review of 283 original studies. The review employed quantitative text analysis to summarize the research field into 18 common topics, which were organized into five coherent categories: citizen's perspective, political elites, political communication, pandemic consequences, and non-COVID-related issues. The studies were analyzed for their analytical frameworks, geographic focuses, and methodological approaches. This systematic approach allowed for a comprehensive mapping of the literature and identification of gaps and patterns.
Introduction
Populism has been frequently cited by media and scholars as a key factor in the mishandling of the COVID-19 crisis. However, the relationship between public health and populism predates the pandemic and extends beyond it. This paper provides a comprehensive overview of existing evidence and theoretical conceptualizations on the intersection of populism, health emergencies, and contrarian scientific positions, drawing from multiple disciplines. The author conducts a scoping review of 283 original studies, analyzing their analytical frameworks, geographic focuses, and methodological approaches. The review aims to synthesize the fragmented literature and propose a more nuanced understanding of how populism interacts with health crises and science.
Why it matters
The author compares definitions of populism within the context of health and scientific positions. The findings suggest that populism's influence on health emergency responses is not uniform; rather, it varies depending on the specific policy arena and contextual factors. The paper proposes that future research should employ a policy typology for health emergency responses, assessing political positions based on policy arenas. This approach would allow for a more precise understanding of how populist politics shape health crises and science contrarianism. The paper contributes to the understanding of the complex interplay between political populism, contrarian scientific perspectives, and public health.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ