Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Pertanian & Lingkungan editorial

Open AccessOA2023

How the Green Architecture of the 2023–2027 Common Agricultural Policy could have been greener

The 2023–2027 Common Agricultural Policy's Green Architecture, despite its potential, fails to deliver significant environmental benefits. The authors propose a more consistent and effective use of conditionality, eco-schemes, and agri-environment measures, grounded in public economics and agroecological research.
H. Guyomard; C. Détang-Dessendre; P. Dupraz; L. Delaby; C. Huyghe; J. Peyraud; X. Reboud; C. Sirami· Ambio· 2023· DOI 10.1007/s13280-023-01861-0

The core problem

The 2023–2027 Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) introduces a 'Green Architecture' built on three instruments: conditionality, eco-schemes, and agri-environment and climate measures (AECM). The authors argue that, like its predecessors, this CAP will fail to deliver significant climatic and environmental benefits. The paper aims to show how the Green Architecture could have been used more consistently and effectively, drawing on core principles of public economics and fiscal federalism, as well as research results in agronomy and ecology. The central premise is that conditionality should set minimal requirements for all producers, while eco-schemes and AECM should reward additional efforts for global and local public goods, respectively.

Innovation

The analysis is based on a conceptual framework derived from public economics and fiscal federalism, which distinguishes between global and local public goods. The authors synthesize findings from agronomy and ecology to propose a redesign of the Green Architecture. They examine the three instruments—conditionality, eco-schemes, and AECM—and evaluate their potential to deliver environmental and climatic benefits. The methodology involves a critical review of the CAP's legal framework and an assessment of how the instruments interact. The authors also discuss trade-offs that their proposals might generate, such as administrative complexity and distributional effects.
Introduction
The 2023–2027 Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) introduces a 'Green Architecture' built on three instruments: conditionality, eco-schemes, and agri-environment and climate measures (AECM). The authors argue that, like its predecessors, this CAP will fail to deliver significant climatic and environmental benefits. The paper aims to show how the Green Architecture could have been used more consistently and effectively, drawing on core principles of public economics and fiscal federalism, as well as research results in agronomy and ecology. The central premise is that conditionality should set minimal requirements for all producers, while eco-schemes and AECM should reward additional efforts for global and local public goods, respectively.

Why it matters

The authors discuss the implications of their proposals, emphasizing the need for a clear division of labor between the three instruments. Conditionality should establish minimal requirements that all farmers must meet, reflecting the 'polluter pays' principle. Eco-schemes should be designed as payments for global public goods, such as climate mitigation and biodiversity conservation, and should be available to all farmers who adopt prescribed practices. AECM should be tailored to local public goods, such as water quality and landscape amenities, and should be implemented through collective approaches where possible. The paper acknowledges potential trade-offs, including increased administrative burden and the risk of unequal distribution of payments. However, it argues that a more consistent and effective Green Architecture is essential for achieving the EU's environmental and climate goals.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…