Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2025
Human-Centric AI Governance: An Adaptive Public International Law Framework for Ethical and Inclusive AI Regulation in Public Health
This study evaluates existing AI governance models and proposes an adaptive public international law framework for AI in public health, emphasizing ethical accountability, regulatory adaptability, and transparency to address jurisdictional gaps and promote equitable outcomes.
Farman Saeed Sedeeq; Perรงem Armanยท Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethicsยท 2025ยท DOI 10.1017/jme.2025.10175
The core problem
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is rapidly transforming public health, offering opportunities for improved diagnostics, treatment, and population health management. However, this transformation brings significant ethical and legal challenges, including concerns about accountability, bias, privacy, and equitable access. Existing governance models, such as the World Health Organization's (WHO) guidance and the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), exhibit critical shortcomings: the WHO's instruments often lack enforceability, while the GDPR's data-sharing rules can be rigid and impede public health research and cross-border collaboration. This study adopts an interdisciplinary approach, integrating legal doctrinal analysis, public health ethics, AI governance scholarship, and a scoping review of international legal instruments to evaluate and operationalize three core pillars: ethical accountability, regulatory adaptability, and transparency. The aim is to propose an adaptive public international law framework that addresses these gaps and ensures that AI in public health is developed and deployed in a human-centric, ethical, and inclusive manner.
Innovation
The research employs a mixed-methods approach combining legal doctrinal analysis, public health ethics, AI governance scholarship, and a scoping review of international legal instruments. The scoping review systematically maps treaties, regional regulations, and policy frameworks relevant to AI in public health, identifying jurisdictional gaps and shortcomings in existing governance models. The doctrinal analysis examines the legal structures and enforceability mechanisms of these instruments, while the ethics component evaluates normative principles such as equity, accountability, and transparency. The synthesis of these methods informs the design of an adaptive public law framework. The framework is developed through a thematic synthesis of global best practices and informed by case studies that illustrate the application of AI in diverse public health contexts. This iterative process ensures that the proposed framework is both grounded in empirical evidence and theoretically robust.
Introduction
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is rapidly transforming public health, offering opportunities for improved diagnostics, treatment, and population health management. However, this transformation brings significant ethical and legal challenges, including concerns about accountability, bias, privacy, and equitable access. Existing governance models, such as the World Health Organization's (WHO) guidance and the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), exhibit critical shortcomings: the WHO's instruments often lack enforceability, while the GDPR's data-sharing rules can be rigid and impede public health research and cross-border collaboration. This study adopts an interdisciplinary approach, integrating legal doctrinal analysis, public health ethics, AI governance scholarship, and a scoping review of international legal instruments to evaluate and operationalize three core pillars: ethical accountability, regulatory adaptability, and transparency. The aim is to propose an adaptive public international law framework that addresses these gaps and ensures that AI in public health is developed and deployed in a human-centric, ethical, and inclusive manner.
Why it matters
The proposed adaptive public international law framework addresses the identified gaps through a modular, scalable design. It operationalizes the three pillars: ethical accountability, regulatory adaptability, and transparency. Ethical accountability is ensured through mechanisms such as mandatory ethical impact assessments, independent oversight bodies, and clear liability rules. Regulatory adaptability is achieved via a modular structure that allows region-specific regulations to be tailored while maintaining interoperability through common principles and standards. Transparency is promoted through requirements for explainable AI, open data practices (where appropriate), and stakeholder engagement. The framework is human-centric, placing individual and community health outcomes at its core, and emphasizes equity and inclusiveness. It leverages international law's soft law instruments, such as guidelines and codes of practice, to complement binding treaties, creating a dynamic and responsive governance ecosystem. Case studies demonstrate the framework's applicability across contexts, from high-income to low-resource settings. The discussion highlights the framework's potential to balance AI-driven innovation with ethical imperatives, fostering trust and promoting equitable public health outcomes globally.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ