Ilmu Sosial editorial
If You See Something, Say Something: Structural Vulnerability Data and Reporting in Forensic Anthropology Casework
The core problem
Forensic anthropologists have long worked across diverse global contexts, but recent debates have focused on the discipline's duties and scope, particularly in the United States. Central to these debates is whether forensic casework should acknowledge **structural vulnerability** or **structural violence**. Kim and Friedlander draw on anthropological scholarship and autoethnographic analysis to argue that forensic anthropology skills should be used to evaluate sociocultural information, especially that of structural violence and vulnerability. This expansion is linked to concurrent critiques of the forensic anthropologist's role and the problematic use of biological profile estimates. Typically, contemporary casework involves examining decomposing and skeletal remains to assist identification through estimates of age, sex, stature, and ancestry; postmortem interval; and information contributing to cause and manner of death conclusions. The authors propose moving forensic anthropology toward additional routes of inquiry. Their positionality brings unique applied experience: the first author has experience in both domestic casework and ethnographic forensic human rights research abroad, while the second author works as a forensic anthropologist within law enforcement to routinely track missing persons and search, locate, and recover unidentified human remains (UHRs). Both recognize the practical and ethical assistance that a structural vulnerability or structural violence lens provides.
Structural violence, social vulnerability, and marginalization have diverse and deep-seated bodies of literature. For this analysis, structural violence is loosely defined following Galtung, Scheper-Hughes and Bourgois, and Farmer as policies, practices, and beliefs that deny members of a non-dominant group access to resources, thus placing them in harm's way. Limited access to resources can manifest in forensic casework, so forensic anthropologists are uniquely positioned to capture potential policy-changing evidence in addition to forensic evidence. Public health and disaster literatures often frame marginalization in terms of social vulnerability, underscoring factors that make particular social identities more at risk during public health crises and disaster mitigation/relief. The paper draws on both concepts, but the theoretical minutiae are beyond its primary focus: What data related to marginalization should be collected and what should be done with it in forensic casework? There has been growing interest in the use and applicability of both skeletal and non-skeletal data that could be gathered by the forensic anthropologist to generate sociocultural inferences. As law enforcement and medical examiners increasingly call upon anthropologists to assist in search and recovery efforts, anthropologists have the opportunity to analyze contextual information from the scene that could contribute useful information to understanding the dynamics and/or circumstances that contributed to delayed discovery. Furthermore, health indicator data from skeletal analyses may reflect resource voids or structural issues that impact the lived experiences of the deceased. This piece recognizes the burgeoning ethical pressures to reimagine forensic anthropology for the twenty-first century and contributes to debates that explore repositioning casework in a more comprehensive anthropological approach, buttressing recent publications on structural violence (i.e., lack of access to resources) and social vulnerability witnessed in forensic investigations. The piece considers the ethical duties of anthropologists as agents in society, discusses what is meant by structural vulnerability data in forensic anthropological literature, and then unpacks the challenging question of what meaningful action an anthropologist can take with said data.
Innovation
Why it matters
Who should read this
Opening member content…