Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Ekonomi & Bisnis editorial

Open AccessOA2024

Impact of global heterogeneity of renewable energy supply on heavy industrial production and green value chains

A new study quantifies the 'renewables pull'—energy-cost savings from relocating energy-intensive production to regions with cheap renewable electricity. For steel, urea, and ethylene, an electricity-price difference of €40/MWh yields savings of 18%, 32%, and 38%, respectively, potentially driving green relocation.
Philipp C. Verpoort; Lukas Gast; Anke Hofmann; F. Ueckerdt· Nature Energy· 2024· DOI 10.1038/s41560-024-01492-z

The core problem

The global transition to climate neutrality is expected to alter the geography of energy-intensive industries. As renewable electricity costs vary widely across regions, production of basic materials such as steel and chemicals may relocate to areas with abundant and cheap renewables. This study investigates the 'renewables pull'—the energy-cost savings that could motivate such relocation—for three key tradable commodities: steel, urea, and ethylene. The authors examine how different depths of relocation (from partial to full production shifts) affect cost savings, and compare relocation with alternative strategies like shipping hydrogen or trading intermediate products.

Innovation

The analysis estimates the energy-cost savings from relocating production for varying depths of the value chain. For each commodity, the authors calculate the cost difference between producing in a region with high renewable electricity prices and one with low prices, assuming an electricity-price difference of €40 per MWh. The depth of relocation ranges from partial (e.g., moving only energy-intensive steps) to full relocation. The study also evaluates alternative options: conserving current production patterns by shipping hydrogen, and trading intermediate products. The methodology likely employs cost modeling based on industry data and energy prices, though specific details are not provided in the abstract.
Introduction
The global transition to climate neutrality is expected to alter the geography of energy-intensive industries. As renewable electricity costs vary widely across regions, production of basic materials such as steel and chemicals may relocate to areas with abundant and cheap renewables. This study investigates the 'renewables pull'—the energy-cost savings that could motivate such relocation—for three key tradable commodities: steel, urea, and ethylene. The authors examine how different depths of relocation (from partial to full production shifts) affect cost savings, and compare relocation with alternative strategies like shipping hydrogen or trading intermediate products.

Why it matters

The findings suggest that regional heterogeneity in renewable energy prices could drive a global relocation of energy-intensive production, leading to 'green relocation.' However, such shifts have significant implications for renewable-scarce regions, including macroeconomic, industrial, and geopolitical consequences. The authors argue that a societal debate is needed in these regions to consider selective policies of green-relocation protection. The study highlights that while relocation may be economically efficient, it could disrupt existing industrial structures and employment. Policymakers must weigh the benefits of cost savings against the risks of deindustrialization and strategic dependencies. The analysis underscores the need for coordinated international strategies to manage the transition.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…