Fisika & Matematika editorial
Open AccessOA2024
Intelligent Tutoring Systems in Mathematics Education: A Systematic Literature Review Using the SAMR Model
This systematic review examines 20 years of empirical research on intelligent tutoring systems (ITSs) in mathematics education through the lens of the SAMR model. Findings indicate that ITSs mostly augment existing learning, but recent studies show transformative potential, especially when teacher roles and educational contexts are aligned.
Taekwon Son· De Computis· 2024· DOI 10.3390/computers13100270
The core problem
Scholars have claimed that artificial intelligence (AI) can transform education, but evidence on whether intelligent tutoring systems (ITSs)—a representative form of AI in education—have transformed mathematics teaching and learning is insufficient. To address this gap, this systematic review examines empirical studies from 2003 to 2023 that used ITSs in mathematics education. The review employs the substitution, augmentation, modification, redefinition (SAMR) model, extended to suit ITSs in mathematics education, to code technology integration. It also explores how different contexts and teacher roles intertwine with SAMR levels. The central research questions are: (1) To what extent do ITSs in mathematics education reach different SAMR levels? (2) How do educational contexts (e.g., school level, content area) relate to SAMR levels? (3) How is the teacher's role intertwined with SAMR levels?
Innovation
A systematic literature review was conducted following PRISMA guidelines. Empirical studies published between 2003 and 2023 that implemented ITSs in mathematics education were identified through searches in major databases (e.g., Web of Science, Scopus, ERIC). Inclusion criteria required that studies report empirical outcomes of ITS use in mathematics learning. The SAMR model was extended for ITSs: **Substitution** (technology acts as a direct substitute with no functional change), **Augmentation** (technology acts as a direct substitute with functional improvement), **Modification** (technology allows for significant task redesign), and **Redefinition** (technology allows for creation of new tasks previously inconceivable). Each study was coded for SAMR level, educational context (school level, content area), and teacher role (e.g., minimized intervention, facilitator). Inter-rater reliability was established. Data were synthesized qualitatively and quantitatively.
Introduction
Scholars have claimed that artificial intelligence (AI) can transform education, but evidence on whether intelligent tutoring systems (ITSs)—a representative form of AI in education—have transformed mathematics teaching and learning is insufficient. To address this gap, this systematic review examines empirical studies from 2003 to 2023 that used ITSs in mathematics education. The review employs the substitution, augmentation, modification, redefinition (SAMR) model, extended to suit ITSs in mathematics education, to code technology integration. It also explores how different contexts and teacher roles intertwine with SAMR levels. The central research questions are: (1) To what extent do ITSs in mathematics education reach different SAMR levels? (2) How do educational contexts (e.g., school level, content area) relate to SAMR levels? (3) How is the teacher's role intertwined with SAMR levels?
Why it matters
The results suggest that while ITSs have largely been used to enhance existing practices (augmentation), their transformative power is realized when the **affordance of the ITS**, the **educational context**, and the **teacher's role** are considered simultaneously. The predominance of elementary-level and basic content areas indicates that ITSs are often employed for foundational skills, where drill-and-practice is common. However, to achieve redefinition, ITSs must be integrated into tasks that require complex problem solving, reasoning, and collaboration—areas where teacher facilitation is crucial. The finding that most studies minimized teacher intervention raises concerns: teachers' active involvement may be necessary to scaffold learning and to leverage ITSs for transformative purposes. The extended SAMR model provides a useful framework for evaluating the integration of ITSs, but future research should explore how teacher professional development and contextual factors influence the SAMR level achieved. Limitations include the focus on empirical studies and potential publication bias. Implications for practice and policy are discussed.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…