Teknik & Rekayasa editorial
Open AccessOA2023
Investigation study of integrated vocational guidance on work readiness of mechanical engineering vocational school students
This study investigates the effect of integrated vocational guidance on work readiness of mechanical engineering vocational school students. Using a quasi-experimental design, it compares demonstration and explanation methods, finding that the demonstration method leads to better work readiness (knowledge, attitudes, skills) above the Minimum Completeness Criteria.
Rochmad Novian Inderanata; T. Sukardiยท Heliyonยท 2023ยท DOI 10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e13333
The core problem
The 21st Century Learning paradigm shifts the way of learning and teaching, requiring educators to organize education that encompasses three aspects of work readiness: knowledge, attitudes, and skills. Many educators rely solely on the explanation method in vocational guidance, neglecting the demonstration method of learning machining practices related to how to work, behave in the workplace, and comply with regulations. This results in graduates with minimal competence, not meeting industry standards. This study aims to determine the effect of integrated vocational guidance on student work readiness in Vocational High Schools. The research addresses the gap by comparing an explanation method (control group) with a demonstration method (experimental group) in the context of mechanical engineering vocational education.
Innovation
This research is quasi-experimental with a quantitative approach, using a pretest-posttest non-equivalent control group design. The control group received the explanation method, where the teacher explains how the machine works verbally. The experimental group received the demonstration method, where the teacher demonstrates how the machine works and operates it, followed by student activities practicing it again in the machine laboratory. The population comprised students of the Mechanical Engineering Expertise Program. Data collection involved observation and tests: observations were used to collect data on technical skills and work attitudes, while tests were used to collect data on aspects of basic knowledge. The study likely employed statistical tests such as t-tests or ANCOVA to compare groups, though specific details are not provided in the source.
Introduction
The 21st Century Learning paradigm shifts the way of learning and teaching, requiring educators to organize education that encompasses three aspects of work readiness: knowledge, attitudes, and skills. Many educators rely solely on the explanation method in vocational guidance, neglecting the demonstration method of learning machining practices related to how to work, behave in the workplace, and comply with regulations. This results in graduates with minimal competence, not meeting industry standards. This study aims to determine the effect of integrated vocational guidance on student work readiness in Vocational High Schools. The research addresses the gap by comparing an explanation method (control group) with a demonstration method (experimental group) in the context of mechanical engineering vocational education.
Why it matters
The study's findings highlight the importance of integrated vocational guidance that includes demonstration methods to enhance work readiness. The demonstration method allows students to observe and practice real-world tasks, bridging the gap between theory and practice. This aligns with the demands of 21st Century Learning, which emphasizes skills such as critical thinking, collaboration, and practical problem-solving. The research has practical implications for vocational teachers: they should incorporate demonstration methods in vocational guidance services, especially leveraging technological advances such as the internet, digital technology, VR/AR, etc., to simulate workplace scenarios and enhance learning. However, the study's limitations include the lack of detailed statistical analysis and the specific context of mechanical engineering, which may limit generalizability. Future research could explore the long-term impact of such methods and include larger, more diverse samples.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ