Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2022
Islamic Law and National Law (Comparative Study of Islamic Criminal Law and Indonesian Criminal Law)
This study compares Islamic criminal law and Indonesian criminal law, finding that Islamic law aims to preserve human benefit (maslahah) in this world and the hereafter, while Indonesian criminal law focuses on crime prevention and deterrence. It also notes the partial application of Islamic criminal law in Aceh and the incorporation of Islamic legal values into various Indonesian regulations.
M. Yasir; J. Widodo; A. Asharยท Jurnal Hukum Islamยท 2022ยท DOI 10.30983/alhurriyah.v6i2.4952
The core problem
The Indonesian state is not an Islamic state, yet Islamic legal values are substantively incorporated, either partially or wholly, into various laws and regulations, such as the Marriage Law, Waqf Law, Hajj Law, and Banking Law (including Law No. 10/1998 and Law No. 21/2008). Islamic criminal law has been implemented only in the Province of Aceh Darus Salam, and only a small part of it. This study aims to describe Islamic law and Islamic criminal law, and to determine the objectives of Islamic law and Indonesian criminal law. The research employs a qualitative method with a normative juridical approach.
Innovation
The study uses a qualitative method with a normative juridical approach. This approach involves analyzing legal norms and principles derived from primary legal sources, including the Qur'an, Sunnah, and Ra'yu/Ijtihad for Islamic law, as well as Indonesian statutory laws and regulations. The analysis focuses on comparing the objectives and characteristics of Islamic criminal law and Indonesian criminal law.
Introduction
The Indonesian state is not an Islamic state, yet Islamic legal values are substantively incorporated, either partially or wholly, into various laws and regulations, such as the Marriage Law, Waqf Law, Hajj Law, and Banking Law (including Law No. 10/1998 and Law No. 21/2008). Islamic criminal law has been implemented only in the Province of Aceh Darus Salam, and only a small part of it. This study aims to describe Islamic law and Islamic criminal law, and to determine the objectives of Islamic law and Indonesian criminal law. The research employs a qualitative method with a normative juridical approach.
Why it matters
The findings highlight a fundamental difference in objectives: Islamic criminal law is oriented toward the preservation of five essential elements (religion, life, intellect, property, and honor) and the maintenance of maslahah for worldly and otherworldly happiness, whereas Indonesian criminal law is more focused on social order through crime prevention and deterrence. The partial implementation of Islamic criminal law in Aceh reflects the limited scope of its application within the Indonesian legal system. The incorporation of Islamic legal values into national regulations demonstrates a selective integration rather than a full adoption of Islamic criminal law. This comparative analysis underscores the distinct philosophical underpinnings of the two legal systems, with Islamic law rooted in divine revelation and Indonesian law in state sovereignty.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ