Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholatโ€ฆ

Hukum editorial

Open AccessOA2025

Judicial Activism of the Constitutional Court in Progressive Law Discovery: Limitations, Checks and Balances, and the Threat of Becoming a Positive Legislator

This study examines judicial activism by Indonesia's Constitutional Court as progressive law discovery, assessing risks to separation of powers and the Court acting as a positive legislator. It analyzes two landmark decisions to propose interpretive limits and judicial self-restraint.
Nur Hasanah; I. Triadiยท Siyasah Dusturiyah: State Law Reviewยท 2025ยท DOI 10.65101/dv2vw205

The core problem

The study addresses judicial activism of Indonesia's Constitutional Court (Mahkamah Konstitusi) as a form of progressive law discovery (Rechtvinding) within a civil law tradition. It questions whether such activism, intended to fill gaps in codified law, threatens the doctrine of separation of powers by transforming the Court into a positive legislator. The research is situated in the tension between substantive justice and legislative sovereignty, and aims to identify limitations and checks and balances to preserve constitutional supremacy.

Innovation

Employing a doctrinal legal research method, the analysis synthesizes statutory texts, case law, and scholarly commentary through hermeneutic and comparative techniques. The approach focuses on constitutional review decisions to evaluate interpretive practices and their institutional implications.
Introduction
The study addresses judicial activism of Indonesia's Constitutional Court (Mahkamah Konstitusi) as a form of progressive law discovery (Rechtvinding) within a civil law tradition. It questions whether such activism, intended to fill gaps in codified law, threatens the doctrine of separation of powers by transforming the Court into a positive legislator. The research is situated in the tension between substantive justice and legislative sovereignty, and aims to identify limitations and checks and balances to preserve constitutional supremacy.

Why it matters

The study analyzes the implications of these decisions for the separation of powers. It argues that judicial activism must be constrained by codified interpretive limits and judicial self-restraint to maintain coherent jurisprudence. The authors propose:

1. Codifying interpretive limits to guide constitutional review.
2. Promoting judicial self-restraint to avoid overreach.
3. Enhancing legislative responsiveness to reduce the need for judicial lawmaking.

These recommendations aim to fortify Indonesia's constitutional order by balancing judicial innovation with the integrity of democratic lawmaking. The analysis underscores the importance of checks and balances in preserving constitutional supremacy while allowing for progressive law discovery.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member contentโ€ฆ