Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2026
Judicial Interpretation as Power: The Crisis of Judicial Imagination in Indian Constitutional Law: A Mimamsa Perspective
This paper argues that Indian constitutional interpretation is a site of power that reproduces social hierarchies, and proposes Mimamsa hermeneutics as a critical tool to interrogate judicial authority and discretion.
Pratham Ahuja· Social Science Research Network· 2026· DOI 10.2139/ssrn.6256698
The core problem
The paper contends that constitutional and statutory interpretation in India is not merely a technical exercise of resolving textual ambiguity, but a constitutive site where legal authority, social hierarchy, and developmental priorities are reproduced. Modern techniques of interpretation—textual, purposive, and value-based—are embedded in an implicit judicial imagination that privileges neutrality, abstraction, and progress, often at the expense of the relational harms and structural inequalities embedded in legal disputes. The author argues that the limits of these techniques are not merely doctrinal, but epistemic and moral, based on patriarchal assumptions and a development-centric understanding of constitutional governance. To shed light on these limitations, the article uses the principles of Mimamsa hermeneutics as a critical tool of interpretation in place of a normative alternative to modern constitutional reasoning.
Innovation
The paper employs a critical and comparative methodology. It critically analyzes modern techniques of interpretation (textual, purposive, and value-based) to reveal their embedded assumptions and limitations. It then introduces Mimamsa hermeneutics as a critical lens, drawing on its principles of interpretive modesty, contextual holism, and obligation-driven reasoning. The method is not to offer Mimamsa as a normative alternative but to use it as a tool to interrogate the authority of the interpreter and the scope of judicial discretion in Indian constitutional law.
Introduction
The paper contends that constitutional and statutory interpretation in India is not merely a technical exercise of resolving textual ambiguity, but a constitutive site where legal authority, social hierarchy, and developmental priorities are reproduced. Modern techniques of interpretation—textual, purposive, and value-based—are embedded in an implicit judicial imagination that privileges neutrality, abstraction, and progress, often at the expense of the relational harms and structural inequalities embedded in legal disputes. The author argues that the limits of these techniques are not merely doctrinal, but epistemic and moral, based on patriarchal assumptions and a development-centric understanding of constitutional governance. To shed light on these limitations, the article uses the principles of Mimamsa hermeneutics as a critical tool of interpretation in place of a normative alternative to modern constitutional reasoning.
Why it matters
The paper argues that for constitutional adjudication to be more than just a site of doctrinal innovation, there must be a shift towards interpretive modesty, epistemic diversity, and moral responsibility. It discusses how Mimamsa principles can inform a more self-aware and responsible interpretive practice, one that acknowledges the power dynamics inherent in interpretation and seeks to mitigate the harms of abstraction and neutrality. The author contends that the crisis of judicial imagination is rooted in the unchecked expansion of interpretive power, and that a Mimamsa-inspired approach can foster a more humble and context-sensitive jurisprudence.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…