Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2026
Legal Foundations and Implications of International Judgments Concerning Legal Infractions in a Constitutional State Governed by the Rule of Law
This study analyzes the legal foundations and implications of international judgments establishing state responsibility within a constitutional rule of law. It distinguishes state responsibility from criminal sanctions and identifies normative, institutional, and rights-protective dimensions of effectiveness.
Victor Jimmy Cabrera Gomez; H. C. Carbajal Sanchez; Norma Lisbeth Quezada Salirrosas· Universidad, Ciencia y Tecnología· 2026· DOI 10.47460/uct.v30i133.1133
The core problem
The study addresses the legal foundations and implications of international judgments that establish state responsibility within the framework of a constitutional state governed by the rule of law. The research problem centers on understanding how international judicial decisions become binding and effective in domestic legal orders, particularly when they concern legal infractions. The authors aim to analyze the legal basis for the binding force of such judgments and to assess their implications for the protection of fundamental rights. The study is situated in the field of law, with a focus on the intersection of international law and constitutional law. The qualitative, documentary, and doctrinal approach is justified by the need to interpret normative and jurisprudential sources systematically.
Innovation
A qualitative, documentary, and doctrinal legal study was conducted. The methods employed include hermeneutic, systematic, and comparative approaches. Twenty normative, jurisprudential, and doctrinal sources were examined and organized into five analytical categories. The hermeneutic method was used to interpret the meaning of legal texts and judicial decisions. The systematic method allowed for the organization of sources into coherent categories. The comparative method facilitated the contrast between different legal orders and doctrines. The five analytical categories likely correspond to themes such as the nature of state responsibility, the binding force of judgments, dimensions of effectiveness, implementation mechanisms, and rights protection. The documentary analysis focused on primary and secondary sources, including international treaties, case law, and scholarly writings.
Introduction
The study addresses the legal foundations and implications of international judgments that establish state responsibility within the framework of a constitutional state governed by the rule of law. The research problem centers on understanding how international judicial decisions become binding and effective in domestic legal orders, particularly when they concern legal infractions. The authors aim to analyze the legal basis for the binding force of such judgments and to assess their implications for the protection of fundamental rights. The study is situated in the field of law, with a focus on the intersection of international law and constitutional law. The qualitative, documentary, and doctrinal approach is justified by the need to interpret normative and jurisprudential sources systematically.
Why it matters
The analysis reveals that while international judgments are legally binding, their effectiveness depends on domestic implementation. The distinction between state responsibility and criminal sanctions is crucial for understanding the nature of international obligations. State responsibility is primarily corrective and reparative, aiming to restore the legal order, whereas criminal sanctions are punitive. The binding force of international judgments is grounded in the consent of states, as expressed through treaties or customary law. However, the study shows that bindingness alone is insufficient; institutional mechanisms such as domestic courts, legislative incorporation, and executive compliance are necessary. The three dimensions of effectiveness provide a framework for evaluating compliance. The normative dimension requires that judgments be clear and specific. The institutional dimension necessitates the existence of bodies empowered to enforce judgments. The rights-protective dimension focuses on the impact on individuals and groups. The study concludes that international judgments contribute to the protection of fundamental rights, but their effectiveness must be assessed by verifying the implementation of the measures ordered. This implies that scholars and practitioners should focus on actual compliance rather than formal bindingness. The comparative method highlighted variations across legal systems in how international judgments are received. The study's limitations include its reliance on documentary sources and the absence of empirical data on compliance. Future research could examine specific cases of implementation.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…