Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholatโ€ฆ

Hukum editorial

Open AccessOA2026

Legislation and the Constitutional Court: Reconciling Constitutional Justice and Democratic Accountability in Comparative Constitutional Law

This study examines how constitutional courts worldwide, through judicial review, constructively foster democratic accountability rather than merely correcting unconstitutional laws. Using a normative juridical and comparative approach across four countries, it proposes a dialectical and symbiotic framework for understanding legislative legitimacy and constitutional justice.
Muhammad Rum Siolimbona; H. A. Mau; Sineenart Suasoongnernยท International Journal of Lawยท 2026ยท DOI 10.56107/penalaw.v4i1.294

The core problem

The relationship between legislation and constitutional courts has emerged as a central issue in modern constitutional law. Legislation embodies democratic legitimacy, as it is enacted by political majorities. However, these majorities may pass laws that threaten constitutional rights and the rule of law. Constitutional courts, conversely, serve as guardians of constitutional supremacy, ensuring that legislative acts conform to fundamental constitutional values. This study investigates this dynamic, asking whether the tension between legislative will and constitutional justice is necessarily adversarial or can be reconciled. The authors argue that the interaction is dialectical and symbiotic, with constitutional courts playing a constructive role in fostering democratic accountability. The research aims to move beyond country-specific analyses by offering a global comparative perspective and a conceptual framework for understanding how legislative legitimacy and constitutional justice reinforce each other.

Innovation

The study employs a normative juridical and comparative approach. It analyzes constitutional texts, legislation, and landmark judicial decisions from four jurisdictions: Indonesia, Germany, South Africa, and South Korea. These countries were selected to represent diverse constitutional traditions and experiences with judicial review. The research methods include content analysis of legal documents, comparative legal methods to identify similarities and differences, and hermeneutic interpretation to understand the meaning and implications of constitutional provisions and judicial rulings. This multi-method approach allows for a comprehensive examination of how constitutional courts operate within different democratic systems and how they balance legislative legitimacy with constitutional justice.
Introduction
The relationship between legislation and constitutional courts has emerged as a central issue in modern constitutional law. Legislation embodies democratic legitimacy, as it is enacted by political majorities. However, these majorities may pass laws that threaten constitutional rights and the rule of law. Constitutional courts, conversely, serve as guardians of constitutional supremacy, ensuring that legislative acts conform to fundamental constitutional values. This study investigates this dynamic, asking whether the tension between legislative will and constitutional justice is necessarily adversarial or can be reconciled. The authors argue that the interaction is dialectical and symbiotic, with constitutional courts playing a constructive role in fostering democratic accountability. The research aims to move beyond country-specific analyses by offering a global comparative perspective and a conceptual framework for understanding how legislative legitimacy and constitutional justice reinforce each other.

Why it matters

The relationship between legislation and constitutional courts should not be viewed as adversarial; rather, it is a dialectical and symbiotic interaction that promotes constitutional democracy. The authors propose a conceptual framework where legislative legitimacy and constitutional justice reinforce each other through ongoing dialogue. This framework suggests that constitutional courts, by enforcing constitutional norms, actually strengthen democratic processes by ensuring that legislation reflects fundamental values and protects rights. The comparative perspective highlights that while institutional designs vary, the underlying dynamic is similar: courts and legislatures engage in a cooperative enterprise to realize constitutional democracy. The novelty of this research lies in its global comparative perspective, moving beyond country-specific analyses. It contributes to theoretical debates in comparative constitutional law and offers practical recommendations for improving judicial review and legislative processes in democratic systems. The study emphasizes that judicial review should be understood as a mechanism for enhancing democratic accountability, not as a counter-majoritarian difficulty.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member contentโ€ฆ